A transparency report for pet parents

Pet Supplement Brand Transparency Report 2026

Nov 15, 2026: Plano Paws label/accessibility and Pawfy expert-role corrections; other criterion dates retained.

56 ranked competitors · publisher benchmark shown separately

What changed

Nov 15, 2026: Plano Paws label/accessibility and Pawfy expert-role corrections; other criterion dates retained.

Median of the 56 ranked records: 68.25/100. These aggregates describe this publication’s dated records, not a new audit of the whole market.

Nutramax Laboratories

74.5/100 under the published rubric.

Nutramax scores 74.5/100 under the existing public-disclosure rubric. The reviewed core product families publish substantial label and manufacturing information, named veterinary leadership and specific testing processes. Public research exists; citation placement and batch-result access remain less complete.

Criterion scores and reasons
CriterionScoreWeightEvidence and limits
label dose transparency8/1015The sampled Cosequin MSM tablet, Dasuquin MSM soft chews, Denamarin chewable tablet and Welactin Advanced 3TA liquid publish named active amounts and serving directions. Proviable-DC identifies seven strains but guarantees their combined CFU count. Dasuquin Senior provides individual core amounts and a separately named three-ingredient blend total. This is a five-family representative sample with Senior as a variation check, not a census of every Nutramax SKU. ASU values are standardized powder amounts; EPA+DHA totals are not separate EPA/DHA amounts.
scientific rationale disclosure7/1010Denamarin explains SAMe, glutathione and silybin with references; Dasuquin explains cartilage roles and its ingredient combination; Proviable explains the different roles of probiotics and prebiotics. Explanations on the sampled Cosequin and Welactin pages are shorter and predominantly benefit-oriented. The score describes the consistency of public explanations, not whether the ingredients work or every mechanism is clinically established at the supplied dose.
evidence clinical citation transparency6/1015Denamarin publishes author/journal references linked to public records. The reviewed Proviable and Dasuquin product pages use research language without consistently placing full study identification next to the claim. Public journal papers on Proviable-DC and Dasuquin with MSM are accessible outside the professional portal. Those papers do not establish every claim, all six advertised Proviable studies, all current formulas or Dasuquin Senior outcomes. External discoverability corrects the old all-evidence-gated implication; it does not automatically turn every product page into a well-cited page.
veterinary expert transparency8/1015Public Nutramax news materials name Todd Henderson, DVM, as President and CEO. The quality-audit announcement also names Godwin Omorogieva as Vice President of Quality. These identify people and their disclosed company roles, although they are found in media material rather than a consolidated expert page. Executive leadership is the role verified for Henderson; it is not proof he formulated or reviewed each product. Omorogieva is named with a role, but no professional credential is inferred.
testing coa transparency7/1015The public quality process distinguishes raw-material analytical chemistry and microbiology, internal raw-material COAs, in-process checks, finished-product testing in Nutramax chemistry/microbiology laboratories and stability testing. These are specific testing disclosures. The reviewed quality, product and media sources do not provide a purchaser-facing finished-product lot-to-COA lookup or an enumerated contaminant panel with batch results. This finite finding does not establish that testing or COAs do not exist. A facility auditor is not treated as the product-testing laboratory.
manufacturing quality system transparency9/1010Nutramax identifies owned manufacturing in Lancaster, South Carolina; product contact information supplies the Quality Drive address. Its primary-navigation quality page explains supplier approval, incoming-material checks, cGMP/SOPs and production controls. The May 26, 2022 announcement identifies a UL-administered independent GMP conformance assessment. The reviewed public sources do not supply current audit scope or renewal details, or complete ingredient-origin traceability. The 2022 announcement is historical disclosure; this does not establish that current certification or sourcing records are absent.
claim discipline consumer honesty8/1010The sampled product pages primarily use support language and attach survey attribution to veterinarian-recommendation statements. Some research/combination wording is more categorical than the study identification supplied beside it, particularly on Dasuquin and Proviable. This is a sampled disclosure assessment. Survey raw data, every historical advertisement and the clinical substantiation for every support claim were not audited. A study-access gap is not a finding that the advertised benefit is false.
accessibility buyer verifiability7/1010Quality and manufacturing explanations are linked from corporate navigation. Product facts and some references are public across the product domains. Named leadership appears in media material, and additional research is accessible through public journals. Finding the whole record requires moving between product domains, media pages and journal sources; it is not all assembled in a single buyer evidence hub. Professional access is not the only route to all studies.

Sources reviewed through 11 November 2026. Representative US product-family sample: Cosequin US chewable tablets with MSM; Dasuquin US With MSM soft chews, both size formulas; Denamarin US chewable tablets for dogs; Proviable US DC capsules; Welactin US Advanced3TA liquid for dogs,2mL scoop. Dasuquin Senior checked separately for variation. This is not a census of every SKU.

n-cosequin; n-dasuquin; n-dasuquin-about; n-dasuquin-trial; n-denamarin-about; n-denamarin-label; n-media; n-proviable-label; n-proviable-study; n-quality; n-senior; n-story; n-ul; n-welactin

Wholistic Pet Organics

68.5/100 under the published rubric.

68.5/100 under the existing brand-disclosure rubric. Quantified labels, public quality systems and accessible company information earn substantial credit; citation presentation, role specificity and mixed dose formats leave defined gaps.

Criterion scores and reasons
CriterionScoreWeightEvidence and limits
label dose transparency6/1015The eight-product sample has substantial quantities, with recurring grouped blends and mixed analysis/serving bases. Meaningful disclosure earns credit; whole-food nutrient concentrations are not every ingredient’s input weight.
scientific rationale disclosure8/1010Ingredient roles are explained across nutrition, joint, digestive, immune and oil products; some explanations remain benefit-led. Recognized nutrient/enzyme roles receive credit without requiring a new finished-product trial.
evidence clinical citation transparency4/1015Run Free uses therapeutic-style ingredient explanations; the food/supplement page invokes study levels without identifiable study citations. This scores citation presentation in reviewed sources, not whether research exists elsewhere.
veterinary expert transparency6/1015The family mission identifies relevant founder education and development history, but current scientific roles need interpretation. No requirement for a separate named formulator for every product is imposed.
testing coa transparency7/1015A risk-based third-party testing program and release controls are described; public lot-report access remains limited. NASC audit is credited separately and not recast as a product laboratory report.
manufacturing quality system transparency10/1010Own Bedford manufacturing, quality programs, supplier controls and lot traceability are reachable through primary navigation. Full credit is for disclosure; it does not independently certify each registration or operational claim.
claim discipline consumer honesty7/1010Normal-support positioning coexists with broad nutrition and therapeutic-style benefit language whose supporting evidence is not surfaced. This is a qualified presentation judgment, not a finding of deception or product ineffectiveness.
accessibility buyer verifiability9/1010Quality and family history are accessible through Why Wholistic; ingredient rationale is accessible through product navigation. The evidence is distributed across primary links rather than consolidated into one complete evidence hub.

Sources reviewed through 11 November 2026. Representative sample of eight products: Canine Complete, Feline Complete, Joint Mobility, Run Free, Digest-All, Total Immune, multivitamin soft chews and Salmon Oil. Purposeful representative public-product sample, not best-disclosed-SKU selection: foundational dog/cat powders, broad and concentrated joint powders, digestive powder, immune powder, multi soft chew and omega oil.

w-canine; w-feline; w-joint; w-runfree; w-immune; w-chew; w-digest; w-salmon; w-quality; w-nasc; w-mission; w-why; w-food

Symbol key How to read the badges and watchouts Brand signals · watchouts

Each ranking row earns badges for what the brand publishes well, and may carry up to three Worth Noting watchouts for limitations buyers should be aware of. The same rules apply to every brand on this page, including La Petite Labs.

Public Evidence System
The brand publishes buyer-verifiable evidence across the main pillars — label disclosure, ingredient rationale, clinical evidence, named experts — at a level a buyer can independently check before purchase.
Flagship
Named Experts
The brand surfaces at least one named veterinarian, nutritionist, or scientific advisor with credentials and disclosed scope of involvement (formulator, reviewer, advisor, commentator).
Ingredient Rationale
The brand publishes ingredient-by-ingredient rationale explaining why each meaningful active is in the formula and what biological role it plays.
Disease-Claim-Free
The brand avoids disease-treatment claims, lifespan guarantees, "clinically proven" language without citation, and other consumer-protective language failures across its marketing surface.
Public COA Lookup
The brand publishes a public lookup for Certificates of Analysis (lab reports) so buyers can see test results for actives, contaminants, and microbial purity.
Per-Lot Traceability
Buyers can match a specific bottle or pouch (by lot number) to its own lab report — not just a generic sample COA.
NASC Member
The brand is a current member of the National Animal Supplement Council with active Quality Seal participation.
Finished-Formula Trial
The brand has published a clinical study of the finished formula (not borrowed from an individual ingredient). Distinct from "clinically tested" marketing language.
Named Mfg Facility
The brand discloses its manufacturing facility at the named-facility level (facility name, city, state) with at least one quality-system certification visible.
Worth Noting · watchouts Watchouts describe a documented observation within the review scope. They do not establish product safety, efficacy or the absence of undisclosed practices.
Closed Science
The brand publishes strong testing or COA evidence but does not surface ingredient rationale, named experts, or finished-formula evidence. Testing alone is not enough to make the science verifiable.
Borrowed Evidence
The brand uses "clinically tested," "clinically proven," "study-backed," or trial-adjacent language without surfacing finished-formula or properly qualified ingredient-level evidence.
Unnamed Experts
The brand uses "veterinarian formulated," "expert designed," or similar language without any publicly named individual, credentials, or role.
Active Identity Withheld
The brand uses proprietary blends, grouped amounts, or other label conventions that prevent a buyer from reading the per-active dose on at least one product in the line. Distinct from Line Inconsistency — captures the case where actives are hidden, not where products differ.
Line Inconsistency
Disclosure varies materially across the brand line — one product is well-disclosed, others are not. Buyers may not know which product they are comparing.
Evidence Buried
The brand technically publishes meaningful science, evidence, testing, or expert disclosure, but buyers cannot reach it without dedicated effort. Evidence that exists but is hard to find counts less.
Higher scores reward

Breadth, disclosure, and substantiation.

  • Brands score high when buyers can independently verify the formula, science, named experts, testing, and claims — without emailing support or trusting marketing language.
  • Per-active milligram amounts disclosed on the public label.
  • Named third-party lab, published Certificate of Analysis, lot-level traceability.
  • Public substantiation for marketing claims — citations, not adjectives.
Lower scores may mean

Narrower scope, or less of the work published.

  • Brands score lower when evidence is missing, hidden behind support contact, or substituted with vague language ("clinically tested," "veterinarian-formulated," "third-party verified") that cannot be checked.
  • Actives are listed without per-serving amounts (proprietary blends).
  • Testing language is vague — no named lab, no public COA, no lot linkage.
  • Claims outrun the public evidence record at time of review.

Every number below is a public transparency score: what a buyer can verify from public materials before purchase — not effectiveness, safety, ingredient quality, or customer satisfaction. Read the full methodology.

  1. ElleVet Sciences product photo
    1
    Rank
    87/100
    as of 2026-06-13
    Strong
    1
    Rank
    ElleVet Sciences

    ElleVet Sciences

    ElleVet Sciences

    South Portland, Maine, United States
    87/100
    as of 2026-06-13
    Strong

    ElleVet Sciences sits well above the category median on research and expert disclosure: it cites peer-reviewed finished-formula trials with authors and journals, names a credentialed CMO and Advisory Board from primary navigation, and runs a public lot-linked COA lookup with a named lab. The gaps are in label granularity (cannabinoids grouped as a proprietary CBD + CBDA total), COA panel scope (potency-only on the surfaced certificate), and facility-level manufacturing identity, which stays at region and corporate-HQ level.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreePublic COA LookupPer-Lot TraceabilityNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Publishes a research library of clinical, safety and pharmacokinetic studies on its CBD + CBDA formulations with direct publication links; the current overview reports over 23 peer-reviewed publications.
    • Surfaces a fully named Chief Medical Officer (Dr. Joseph Wakshlag, DVM, PhD, DACVIM, DACVSMR) and a deep Advisory Board of board-certified diplomates with detailed bios, reachable from primary navigation.
    • Operates a public, self-serve, lot-linked COA lookup with the third-party lab (ProVerde) named, and publishes detailed receptor-level ingredient mechanism content on its Science page.

    What's not in it

    • Cannabinoid actives are disclosed as a combined CBD + CBDA total under a proprietary complete-spectrum label across the line, with minor cannabinoids and terpenes unquantified per serving.
    • The publicly pullable COA shows cannabinoid potency only; the heavy-metal, pesticide, and microbial panels described in the FAQ are not surfaced on the lot certificate.
    • The FAQ states GMP-certified manufacture and NASC membership, but does not identify the manufacturing facility or the GMP certifier.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    GMP/research details corrected November 14, 2026; criterion values unchangedSources: 16 sources reviewed
    In-depth ElleVet Sciences review →
    1
    ElleVet Sciences
    ElleVet Sciences
    ElleVet Sciences
    ElleVet Sciences sits well above the category median on research and expert disclosure: it cites peer-reviewed finished-formula trials with authors and journals, names a credent...
    87/100
    Strong
    Full review →
  2. 2
    Rank
    FP

    Fera Pets

    Fera Pet Organics

    United States
    80.0/100
    as of 2026-05-23
    Strong

    Fera Pets presents above the DTC median on named-expert disclosure and operates a real lot-linked COA lookup. The brand publishes mechanism content with ingredient-level citations and avoids disease-treatment claim language. Substance gaps cluster on the legacy product line — flagship chewables disclose every active dose while powders and toppers fall back to total-blend amounts — and on facility-level manufacturing identity, which is held at country and certification-body level only.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreePublic COA LookupPer-Lot TraceabilityNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Fully named five-member Vet Advisory Board with two ACVIM/ACVD board-certified diplomates and disclosed credentials — one of the stronger named-expert disclosures in the DTC pet supplement universe.
    • Functional lot-linked COA lookup tool accepting LOT numbers or product names — real buyer-usable testing transparency rather than a placeholder badge.
    • Brand-level Ingredients encyclopedia publishes per-ingredient mechanism content with linked peer-reviewed studies for most meaningful actives, including ashwagandha, milk thistle, glucosamine, and probiotic strains.

    What's not in it

    • Label transparency varies materially across the line: chewable SKUs disclose every active in mg / IU / CFU while legacy powders (Probiotic Supplement, Mushroom Blend, Whole Food Multivitamin Topper) use total-blend amounts or generic descriptors.
    • Manufacturing facility is not named at facility / city / state level — only 'manufactured in the USA in an FDA-registered GMP facility, NASC certified' country-level disclosure.
    • COA panel scope (which contaminants, microbials, potency assays) is not surfaced on the public Sustainability hub; third-party lab (Eurofins) is named only on the Fish Oil PDP rather than consistently across the line.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Testing/manufacturing updated November 14, 2026; other criteria May 23, 2026Sources: 14 sources reviewed
    In-depth Fera Pets review →
    2
    FP
    Fera Pets
    Fera Pet Organics
    Fera Pets presents above the DTC median on named-expert disclosure and operates a real lot-linked COA lookup. The brand publishes mechanism content with ingredient-level citatio...
    80.0/100
    Strong
    Full review →
  3. PetHonesty product photo
    3
    Rank
    78/100
    as of 2026-11-12
    Solid With Gaps
    3
    Rank
    PetHonesty

    PetHonesty

    Pet Honesty, LLC — per current company privacy policy

    Dog and cat supplements
    78/100
    as of 2026-11-12
    Solid With Gaps

    Numerical labels, named expert roles, public study accounts and an ORIVO oil-origin certificate; pooled components, formula matching, full study details and analytical testing scope remain limitations.

    Public Evidence System Named ExpertsIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Audited Listing Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Meaningful numerical labels across 15 sampled oral families
    • Named experts with individual roles and public study accounts
    • ORIVO species/origin certificate with oil batch identifiers

    What's not in it

    • Pooled components, obscured amounts and formula/version mismatches
    • Study-summary access and uncertain current-formula matching
    • Oil origin verification is not a full analytical COA for every product
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence and editorial review November 12, 2026Sources: 56 criterion/article sources + 2 identity sources; 15 oral product families
    In-depth PetHonesty review →
    3
    PetHonesty
    PetHonesty
    Pet Honesty, LLC — per current company privacy policy
    Numerical labels, named expert roles, public study accounts and an ORIVO oil-origin certificate; pooled components, formula matching, full study details and analytical testing s...
    78/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  4. YuMOVE product photo
    4
    Rank
    77.5/100
    as of 2026-06-13
    Disclosure Gaps
    4
    Rank
    YuMOVE

    YuMOVE

    Lintbells Ltd

    United Kingdom
    77.5/100
    as of 2026-06-13
    Disclosure Gaps

    YuMOVE publishes joint-formula study summaries and ingredient papers, a named current veterinary team, and NASC programme disclosure. The current US navigation links experts and veterinary resources; public lot results remain unresolved.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Current primary navigation links named veterinary advisers and technical-team biographies with credentials and role descriptions.
    • Public veterinary resources separate the RVC joint-formula study summary from ingredient papers and link the manufacturer detailer.
    • The manufacturer detailer and independent NASC sources document a quality programme including random third-party product testing; USA manufacture is stated.

    What's not in it

    • The reviewed materials do not name the testing laboratory or provide public lot-linked YuMOVE test results.
    • The RVC trial is publicly presented as a data-on-file summary, with finished-formula identity and catalog coverage to be checked for the exact product.
    • Manufacturing disclosure is country-level; the reviewed sources do not name an actual facility, city and state.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    C4 8→10, C5 4→6, C6 7→8 and C8 6→8; total 68.5→77.5. Four other numerical criteria retain original dates; this is not a new full assessment.Sources: 19 dated source records; individual evidence dates retainedFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth YuMOVE review →
    4
    YuMOVE
    YuMOVE
    Lintbells Ltd
    YuMOVE publishes joint-formula study summaries and ingredient papers, a named current veterinary team, and NASC programme disclosure. The current US navigation links experts and...
    77.5/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  5. PetLab Co product photo
    5
    Rank
    77/100
    as of 2026-11-12
    Solid With Gaps
    5
    Rank
    PetLab Co

    PetLab Co

    PetLabCo. — subsidiary of PetLab Group Ltd, per current Terms

    Dog and cat supplements
    77/100
    as of 2026-11-12
    Solid With Gaps

    Quantitative labels, detailed expert roles, a published probiotic-recipe study and specific testing commitments; recurring blends, formula matching, dental-report access and lot-level documents remain limitations.

    Public Evidence System Named ExpertsIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Audited Listing Published Trial: Tested Recipe Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Quantitative product panels with defined serving bases
    • Named expert profiles with described roles
    • Published probiotic-recipe study and specific testing commitments

    What's not in it

    • Recurring pooled blends and formula/version boundaries
    • Current-versus-studied recipe identity and full dental-report access
    • No named product-quality laboratory or public lot-report route established in reviewed sources
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence and editorial review November 12, 2026Sources: 36 criterion/article sources + 2 identity sources; 20 oral product pages, 18 related families
    In-depth PetLab Co review →
    5
    PetLab Co
    PetLab Co
    PetLabCo. — subsidiary of PetLab Group Ltd, per current Terms
    Quantitative labels, detailed expert roles, a published probiotic-recipe study and specific testing commitments; recurring blends, formula matching, dental-report access and lot...
    77/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  6. VetriScience Laboratories product photo
    6
    Rank
    77.0/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Solid With Gaps
    6
    Rank
    VetriScience Laboratories

    VetriScience Laboratories

    FoodScience, LLC

    Dog and cat supplements
    77.0/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Solid With Gaps

    Readable serving-based panels in the declared 12-product sample, current research summaries and named development roles. Some blends remain grouped; full-report access and public lot-report access are limited. This 77.0/100 editorial assessment measures disclosure, not clinical efficacy.

    Public Evidence System Named ExpertsIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Current sampled product panels disclose serving-based quantities in readable HTML.
    • The science hub and accessible 2024 Reference Guide provide study details with product/design limits.
    • Pedro Machado and Elizabeth DeLomba have named roles, credentials and development context in primary navigation.
    • Brand and parent quality programs describe testing and manufacturing; NASC confirms program identity.

    What's not in it

    • Calming biopeptides, dental probiotics and Healthy Gut & Digestion capsule ingredients retain grouped amounts; the sample is not a catalogue census.
    • Most research summaries lack matched full-report links; ingredient, disease-model, cell and human studies do not validate every finished formula.
    • No named analytical laboratory, public current lot report or buyer lot lookup was located in the declared source set. This does not establish absence of internal testing.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence and editorial review November 14, 2026Sources: 27 public source records; 12 current product panels; not a catalogue census
    In-depth VetriScience Laboratories review →
    6
    VetriScience Laboratories
    VetriScience Laboratories
    FoodScience, LLC
    Readable serving-based panels in the declared 12-product sample, current research summaries and named development roles. Some blends remain grouped; full-report access and publi...
    77.0/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  7. AnimalBiome product photo
    7
    Rank
    75.5/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Solid With Gaps
    7
    Rank
    AnimalBiome

    AnimalBiome

    Animal Microbiome Analytics, Inc. dba AnimalBiome

    Oakland, CA
    75.5/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Solid With Gaps

    AnimalBiome publishes peer-reviewed FMT capsule research, named scientific experts and donor-screening detail. Study design, disease-specific findings, grouped mushroom amounts and the dates of manufacturing/COA checks remain important limits.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Published FMT Capsule Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Named scientific and veterinary leaders, including four named PhDs, are publicly visible on the team page under primary navigation.
    • Gut Restore donor and batch screening names two independent third-party labs (IDEXX Reference Laboratories and Antech Diagnostics) with specific pathogen panels.
    • Peer-reviewed capsule studies in cats and dogs and a small controlled trial are publicly readable; the Research Studies page links the observational capsule papers.

    What's not in it

    • The July 3, 2026 source review did not locate public lot-linked COA or manufacturing-facility/certification disclosures; these criteria are carried forward with that date.
    • Observational findings and a small disease-specific controlled trial do not establish broad efficacy. The controlled relapse comparisons were nonsignificant; the 2019 pilot write-up remains separate sponsored trade content.
    • Conventional dose/potency metrics are not disclosed for the flagship Gut Restore capsule, and a secondary product (Skin Rescue) groups eight mushroom species into one blend total without species-level amounts.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Research updated November 14, 2026; other criteria July 3, 2026Sources: 12 sources dated July 3 plus 6 current research/product source records
    In-depth AnimalBiome review →
    7
    AnimalBiome
    AnimalBiome
    Animal Microbiome Analytics, Inc. dba AnimalBiome
    AnimalBiome publishes peer-reviewed FMT capsule research, named scientific experts and donor-screening detail. Study design, disease-specific findings, grouped mushroom amounts ...
    75.5/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  8. Vetoquinol USA product photo
    8
    Rank
    75/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Solid With Gaps
    8
    Rank
    Vetoquinol USA

    Vetoquinol USA

    Vetoquinol USA, Inc.

    Fort Worth, TX, United States
    75/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Solid With Gaps

    The manufacturer shop supplies omega quantities and Zylkene panels missed by the earlier review. Named veterinary contributors, study references and group manufacturing disclosures are public, with product and date limits.

    Public Evidence System Named ExpertsIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Program Clinical Evidence Published Disclosed Production Sites

    What's in it

    • EPA and DHA quantities for the liquid pump
    • Named veterinary technical and education roles
    • Public group manufacturing and quality-system disclosures

    What's not in it

    • A current Zylkene Plus campaign label has inconsistent serving information
    • Studies concern different ingredients and formulas
    • Group quality disclosures do not identify the lab report for an individual US supplement lot
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence reviewed Nov 11, 2026Sources: 13 source records; representative product sample
    In-depth Vetoquinol USA review →
    8
    Vetoquinol USA
    Vetoquinol USA
    Vetoquinol USA, Inc.
    The manufacturer shop supplies omega quantities and Zylkene panels missed by the earlier review. Named veterinary contributors, study references and group manufacturing disclosu...
    75/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  9. 9
    Rank
    NP

    Native Pet

    Native Pet

    St. Louis, Missouri
    75/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Solid With Gaps

    Quantitative sample labels and a named nutritionist; pooled probiotics, scattered research and product-specific certification retain important limits.

    Public Evidence System Named ExpertsIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Audited Listing Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Quantitative facts panels across all four sampled dog formulas
    • Dr. Dan Su is named with credentials and formulation role
    • Ingredient explanations, linked research and an independently documented NASC quality signal

    What's not in it

    • Senior Daily and Skin + Coat pool probiotic quantities
    • The available Clean Label Project certificate lists only The Daily and does not establish current annual renewal
    • No lot-linked analytical-report route or matching finished-formula study located in the reviewed sources
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence reviewed Nov 11, 2026Sources: 17 source records; declared sample
    In-depth Native Pet review →
    9
    NP
    Native Pet
    Native Pet
    Quantitative sample labels and a named nutritionist; pooled probiotics, scattered research and product-specific certification retain important limits.
    75/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  10. Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Supplements product photo
    10
    Rank
    75/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Solid With Gaps
    10
    Rank
    Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Supplements

    Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Supplements

    Nestlé Purina PetCare Company

    St. Louis, MO
    75/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Solid With Gaps

    Purina publishes quantified labels, named researchers and strain-specific references through Purina Institute. Study coverage and exact-formula matching vary, and corporate quality statements do not supply a public report for the buyer's lot.

    Public Evidence System Named ExpertsIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Quantified probiotic and soft-chew labels
    • Named scientific contributors with stated roles
    • Public probiotic research references and biological explanations

    What's not in it

    • Grouped EPA/DHA and unquantified individual Hydra Care osmolytes
    • Uneven research matching across the sampled product families
    • No lot-linked analytical-report route located in the identified sources
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence reviewed Nov 11, 2026Sources: 11 source records; representative product sample
    In-depth Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Supplements review →
    10
    Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Supplements
    Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Supplements
    Nestlé Purina PetCare Company
    Purina publishes quantified labels, named researchers and strain-specific references through Purina Institute. Study coverage and exact-formula matching vary, and corporate qual...
    75/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  11. Nutramax Laboratories product photo
    11
    Rank
    74.5/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Solid With Gaps
    11
    Rank
    Nutramax Laboratories

    Nutramax Laboratories

    Nutramax Laboratories Veterinary Sciences, Inc.

    Lancaster, South Carolina
    74.5/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Solid With Gaps

    Nutramax scores 74.5/100 under the existing public-disclosure rubric. The reviewed core product families publish substantial label and manufacturing information, named veterinary leadership and specific testing processes. Public research exists; citation placement and batch-result access remain less complete.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Named active panels across the sampled core families, with grouped amounts identified rather than overlooked.
    • Owned Lancaster manufacturing, specific internal quality steps and a dated independent UL GMP audit disclosure.
    • Named veterinary executive leadership and public research sources receive credit under their actual disclosed scope.

    What's not in it

    • Representative sample of five established product families, with Senior checked for variation; not every current or historical SKU.
    • No current UL certificate or exact finished-product batch analytical results independently verified.
    • Public citation navigation is uneven; not all research is unavailable and not every product claim was clinically validated.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Reviewed November 11, 2026Sources: Dated primary sources; criterion mappings in the dataset
    In-depth Nutramax Laboratories review →
    11
    Nutramax Laboratories
    Nutramax Laboratories
    Nutramax Laboratories Veterinary Sciences, Inc.
    Nutramax scores 74.5/100 under the existing public-disclosure rubric. The reviewed core product families publish substantial label and manufacturing information, named veterinar...
    74.5/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  12. Four Leaf Rover product photo
    12
    Rank
    74.5/100
    as of 2026-11-13
    Solid With Gaps
    12
    Rank
    Four Leaf Rover

    Four Leaf Rover

    Legal manufacturer not established in this scoped review

    Pet supplements
    74.5/100
    as of 2026-11-13
    Solid With Gaps

    74.5/100 following a finite November 13, 2026 reassessment. Current official galleries disclose numerical labels, Dr Patricia Jordan DVM is named as a formulator, and NASC confirms audited seal eligibility. Remaining gaps concern grouped ingredients, citation context and access to product-specific testing reports.

    Public Evidence System Named DVM FormulatorIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Audited Listing Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Numerical panels were inspected for all 22 standalone oral formulas or foods in the declared sample; the additional offer is a three-product bundle.
    • Our Story and gallery artwork identify Dr Patricia Jordan DVM’s formulation role.
    • The homepage describes an own GMP-compliant Texas plant and testing results on request; NASC independently confirms audited Quality Seal eligibility.

    What's not in it

    • Six of 17 supplement-style panels retain meaningful grouped ingredient or probiotic declarations; food-analysis panels use a different format.
    • Research identifiers are real but incomplete, and Safe-Sea’s broad comparison needs preparation/species/endpoint context.
    • No public lot-report lookup or named performing laboratory was established in the reviewed source set.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence and editorial review November 13, 2026Sources: 56 declared source records; 22 standalone oral formulas/foods + one bundle
    In-depth Four Leaf Rover review →
    12
    Four Leaf Rover
    Four Leaf Rover
    Legal manufacturer not established in this scoped review
    74.5/100 following a finite November 13, 2026 reassessment. Current official galleries disclose numerical labels, Dr Patricia Jordan DVM is named as a formulator, and NASC confi...
    74.5/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  13. Front of the Pack product photo
    13
    Rank
    74/100
    as of 2026-06-13
    Solid With Gaps
    13
    Rank
    Front of the Pack

    Front of the Pack

    DJP Ventures LLC (operating as Front of the Pack)

    Los Angeles, CA
    74/100
    as of 2026-06-13
    Solid With Gaps

    Front of the Pack pairs full per-active mg labeling on both supplements with an unusually well-cited ingredient-evidence catalog and a named, credentialed Chief Science Officer. The gaps are concentrated: finished-product testing is asserted but unverifiable (no named lab, no COA, no lot lookup), the manufacturing facility is held at 'Made in the USA', and 'clinically proven' marketing is applied at the formula level while the underlying studies are ingredient-level.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Full per-active milligram disclosure with no proprietary blends across both current SKUs — The One names all twelve actives with amounts and inactives, and Soothe names all five.
    • Public ingredient-evidence catalog citing studies with author lists, journals, years, study-design flags, and working links, each labelled as a dog, human, or review study.
    • One fully credentialed named expert, Dr. Jamie Peyton (DVM, DACVECC, CVA, CVC, CCRT), surfaced as Chief Science Officer with a dedicated bio page and verifiable qualifications.

    What's not in it

    • No finished-product testing transparency: no named laboratory, no certificate of analysis, and no lot- or batch-level lookup — only an unquantified 'under the microscope eight separate times' claim.
    • The home and Soothe pages disclose Utah manufacturing, but do not name the manufacturing facility or its quality-system certifier.
    • The linked research catalog presents ingredient-level studies; no finished-formula trial was identified there. Broad product-outcome framing remains on the home and Ingredients pages.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    C3 corrected November 14, 2026; other criterion values retain June 13, 2026Sources: 12 sources reviewed
    In-depth Front of the Pack review →
    13
    Front of the Pack
    Front of the Pack
    DJP Ventures LLC (operating as Front of the Pack)
    Front of the Pack pairs full per-active mg labeling on both supplements with an unusually well-cited ingredient-evidence catalog and a named, credentialed Chief Science Officer....
    74/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  14. Bernie's Perfect Poop product photo
    14
    Rank
    72.0/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Solid With Gaps
    14
    Rank
    Bernie's Perfect Poop

    Bernie's Perfect Poop

    Bernie's Best, Inc.

    Austin, Texas, United States
    72.0/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Solid With Gaps

    Bernie’s publishes useful product quantities, research summaries, expert biographies and quality-program details. Grouped amounts, conflicting public versions, partial expert identity and limited public lot evidence remain. The 72.0/100 score measures public disclosure, not safety, efficacy or potency.

    Public Evidence System Named ExpertsIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Quality Seal Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Substantial serving-based quantities on the digestive, joint and omega products, with explicit distinctions between amounts and nutrient guarantees.
    • A captured research library of 24 unique entries, with useful study limitations in sampled summaries; not every paper was independently audited.
    • Public first-name R&D and educational biographies disclose roles, qualifications and institutions.
    • A quality FAQ describes supplier COAs, pathogen/heavy-metal tests, nutritional analysis, US production and SQF/GMP systems.

    What's not in it

    • Probiotic CFU and enzyme totals are grouped; dental-treat and oil disclosures do not quantify every preparation. Public package and HTML versions sometimes disagree.
    • Some research context is dispersed and one K-State citation target is wrong; the correct thesis does not establish a retail-formula trial.
    • Inspected expert biographies use first names. Surname-level identity, per-formula involvement and independently checked qualifications are not established here.
    • No named performing analytical laboratory or public finished-product lot report was located in this finite source set. This is not evidence that testing is absent.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence and editorial review November 14, 2026Sources: 35 public reference destinations: 33 article sources plus two corporate policy pages; seven inspected images across six families, not 35 studies or an all-variant census
    In-depth Bernie's Perfect Poop review →
    14
    Bernie's Perfect Poop
    Bernie's Perfect Poop
    Bernie's Best, Inc.
    Bernie’s publishes useful product quantities, research summaries, expert biographies and quality-program details. Grouped amounts, conflicting public versions, partial expert id...
    72.0/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  15. Only Natural Pet product photo
    15
    Rank
    71.5/100
    as of 2026-11-13
    Solid With Gaps
    15
    Rank
    Only Natural Pet

    Only Natural Pet

    Legal manufacturer not established in this scoped review

    Pet supplements
    71.5/100
    as of 2026-11-13
    Solid With Gaps

    Only Natural Pet discloses quantitative labels, a named veterinary advisor, real ingredient citations and public hemp lot reports. Pooled amounts, conflicting panel versions, partial testing coverage and unlinked clinical assurances remain limitations.

    Public Evidence System Named Veterinary AdvisorIngredient ReferencesDisease-Claim-FreePublic Hemp Lot ReportsSample Hemp Lot IdentifiedNASC Audited Listing Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Quantitative labels across 12 oral product families
    • Named veterinary advisor and real ingredient references
    • Public hemp lot reports naming Eurofins and separate manufacturer results

    What's not in it

    • Pooled ingredients and conflicting current web/gallery versions
    • Historical hemp results do not cover every formula or lot
    • Specific clinical-proof and broad certainty claims lack linked support
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence and editorial review November 13, 2026Sources: 60 declared source records; 12 oral supplement families
    In-depth Only Natural Pet review →
    15
    Only Natural Pet
    Only Natural Pet
    Legal manufacturer not established in this scoped review
    Only Natural Pet discloses quantitative labels, a named veterinary advisor, real ingredient citations and public hemp lot reports. Pooled amounts, conflicting panel versions, pa...
    71.5/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  16. Leap Years product photo
    16
    Rank
    71.5/100
    as of 2026-05-23
    Solid With Gaps
    16
    Rank
    Leap Years

    Leap Years

    Animal Biosciences, Inc.

    United States
    71.5/100
    as of 2026-05-23
    Solid With Gaps

    Direct dog-regimen research, named veterinary leadership and quality-system descriptions are reachable from primary navigation. The study used capsules; it is not a trial of the retail flavored chew itself. Active chemical identities, public lot COAs and a named manufacturing facility remain unverified on these reviewed pages.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Quality Seal Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility
    Worth Noting

    Active Identity Withheld

    The brand uses proprietary blends, grouped amounts, or other label conventions that prevent a buyer from reading the per-active dose on at least one product in the line. Distinct from Line Inconsistency — captures the case where actives are hidden, not where products differ.

    What's in it

    • Published randomized, blinded, placebo-controlled trial of proprietary LY-D6/2 in capsules at NC State, published in Scientific Reports in 2024; the primary 3-month owner-rated cognitive score analysis favored the full-dose group.
    • The primary-navigation Our Story biography names Ginny Rentko, VMD/DACVIM, CEO/CVMO, with development scope and professional experience; trial investigators are named separately.
    • Disease-treatment claims are avoided; clinical-style language ('Clinically tested,' 'Studied in Dogs') is anchored to a real trial that buyers can read at nature.com, not to a phantom study.

    What's not in it

    • Active ingredients are not named at the chemical level — the brand discloses 'NAD Booster' (200mg / 600mg) and 'senolytic' as functional categories, confirms the product does not contain NMN, but never tells the buyer which precursor (NR, NAR, NA) or which senolytic compound (fisetin, quercetin, etc.) is in the formula.
    • Testing disclosure is generic: no named third-party laboratory, no public COA lookup, no per-lot traceability, no itemized contaminant / microbial / pesticide / potency panel.
    • Manufacturing facility is not named at the facility-name / city / state level; sourcing is described as 'globally sourced ingredients' with no named suppliers or countries of origin.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    16
    Leap Years
    Leap Years
    Animal Biosciences, Inc.
    Direct dog-regimen research, named veterinary leadership and quality-system descriptions are reachable from primary navigation. The study used capsules; it is not a trial of the...
    Active Identity Withheld
    71.5/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  17. Pet Naturals product photo
    17
    Rank
    71/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Solid With Gaps
    17
    Rank
    Pet Naturals

    Pet Naturals

    FoodScience, LLC

    Williston, Vermont
    71/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Solid With Gaps

    Quantified sample panels, historical named experts and public testing-program detail; current formula roles, relevant study trails and public lot reports remain limited.

    Public Evidence System Historical Named ExpertsIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Audited Listing Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Numerical panels and serving bases across the 13-product sample
    • Named historical veterinarian and product developers on the company’s own blog
    • Public parent/brand quality details and independently corroborated NASC audited listing

    What's not in it

    • Proprietary biopeptide composition and strain identity remain incomplete
    • Named roles and reported rabbit testing are historical and concern a discontinued line
    • No named analytical lab or public lot-report route located in the reviewed sources
    • Corporate testing details are not mapped to every sampled SKU
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Editorial review November 12, 2026; evidence November 11Sources: 32 primary source records; declared 13-product sample
    In-depth Pet Naturals review →
    17
    Pet Naturals
    Pet Naturals
    FoodScience, LLC
    Quantified sample panels, historical named experts and public testing-program detail; current formula roles, relevant study trails and public lot reports remain limited.
    71/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  18. Finn product photo
    18
    Rank
    71.0/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Solid With Gaps
    18
    Rank
    Finn

    Finn

    Finn Wellness, LLC

    New York, NY
    71.0/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Solid With Gaps

    Finn publishes substantial dose information, readable ingredient research and specific soft-chew testing details. Grouped amounts, public version conflicts, formula-specific expert roles and current lot reports remain the useful checks.

    Public Evidence System Named DVM EndorsersIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreePublic Lab AccessBatch-Code TraceabilityNASC Participant Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Inspected panels across ten oral product families provide substantial quantities, including seven Calming Aid actives per 2.5 g chew and nine Hip & Joint actives per 3.5 g chew. Units include mass, pooled CFU and enzyme activity.
    • Current manufacturer educational articles link readable primary studies and qualify several study designs. The colostrum article distinguishes cell culture from dog trials; the storm article identifies an open-label L-theanine study.
    • Finn describes soft-chew batch testing for Salmonella, Listeria and Enterobacteriaceae, with lot codes tracing suppliers, shifts, testing and processing. Its September 28 article separately calls Digestive Probiotics third-party tested.
    • The help center attributes soft-chew production to a US cGMP-compliant, SQF-certified facility. NASC separately lists Finn as a supplier participant.

    What's not in it

    • Microorganisms and some blends remain pooled. The Multivitamin gallery says vitamin B12 5 mg while the modal says 5 mcg; some gallery serving charts have four bands while FAQs have three. Match the actual package before calculating intake.
    • Citations remain dispersed and require attention to ingredient preparation, dose, species and endpoint. Selected source inspection did not establish finished Finn formula trials or complete support for the brand’s claims.
    • Named placements are endorsements; formula-specific development responsibilities remain unestablished. Some sources spell the third endorser Farren Billand and gallery artwork says Farren Billiard.
    • No named performing laboratory, current product-specific lot report or buyer lot lookup was located in the selected sources. NASC audit/seal evidence does not verify those particular analytical tests.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Assessed November 14, 2026Sources: 33 distinct public reference destinations across ten sampled oral families and research/quality sources
    In-depth Finn review →
    18
    Finn
    Finn
    Finn Wellness, LLC
    Finn publishes substantial dose information, readable ingredient research and specific soft-chew testing details. Grouped amounts, public version conflicts, formula-specific exp...
    71.0/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  19. Open Farm product photo
    19
    Rank
    71.0/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Solid With Gaps
    19
    Rank
    Open Farm

    Open Farm

    Open Farm Inc.

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada
    71.0/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Solid With Gaps

    Open Farm publishes traceable ingredient origins, a named food-recipe nutritionist and a Eurofins supplement-lot report. Supplement-specific expert responsibility, broader panel/lot coverage and facility identity remain limits.

    Public Evidence System Named Food-Recipe NutritionistIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreePublic Pathogen ReportPer-Lot TraceabilityNASC Participant Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • The site publishes a prominent lot-code traceability system for ingredient origins and deeper product information.
    • A named, credentialed in-house veterinary nutritionist (Dr. Moran Tal-Gavriel, DVM, DVSc, Dip. ECVCN) is disclosed with a described role on the FAQ page.
    • Two sampled supplement PDPs (Skin & Coat, Probiotic Chews) both publish quantified guaranteed-analysis values and ingredient-origin details.
    • The inspected Skin & Coat lot report names Eurofins for three pathogen results; NASC separately confirms audit and Quality Seal permission.

    What's not in it

    • Food-recipe responsibility does not identify who developed or reviewed each supplement formula. The additional team is described collectively rather than named individually.
    • The July 3 source review did not locate supplement clinical citations or finished-formula trials; those criterion findings and dates are carried forward.
    • The supplied report concerns one submitted sample and three pathogen tests, not ingredient potency or every current lot. Its two physical pages end with printed Page 3 of 3. The food-focused FAQ’s microbial/mycotoxin testing statement is separate from this supplement sample. The reviewed sources do not identify the supplement manufacturing facility by name, city and state. NASC participation is not a product-lot assay or a clinical result.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Expert/testing/manufacturing updated November 14, 2026; other criteria July 3, 2026Sources: 16 dated source records; three affected criteria updated
    In-depth Open Farm review →
    19
    Open Farm
    Open Farm
    Open Farm Inc.
    Open Farm publishes traceable ingredient origins, a named food-recipe nutritionist and a Eurofins supplement-lot report. Supplement-specific expert responsibility, broader panel...
    71.0/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  20. 20
    Rank
    G

    Glandex

    Vetnique Labs LLC

    70.5/100
    as of 2026-11-14 (C4/C5/C6); other criteria dated 2026-07-03
    Solid With Gaps

    Experts corrected 7→10, testing 4→6 and manufacturing 7→8 on November 14 to credit full named expert roles, the NASC testing programme and stated FDA-registered cGMP USA facility; five other numerical tiers retain the July 3 assessment. Formula-specific powder quantities and the 2018 review are clarified. Testing 6 does not meet the Closed Science threshold.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Original Soft Chews list eight quantified actives; the powder panel provides formula-specific quantities and marks vitamins E and C as beef-flavor-only.
    • The primary-navigation expert page names original Glandex formulator Dr James Bascharon, DVM and a broader advisory roster with credentials and biographies. Biographies state advisory, development, nutrition and technical roles. NASC confirms the audited programme expressly covering Glandex.
    • Ingredient rationale (fiber mechanism, anti-inflammatory pathway, gut-microbiome support) is explained consistently across the entire product line, not just the flagship.

    What's not in it

    • The sampled product pages repeat generic clinical wording without an identified supporting study. The published 2018 Glandex review reports postmarketing experience without trial methods, sample size or a control group.
    • The reviewed materials do not identify a testing laboratory or provide a public lot-linked COA or test-panel results.
    • Manufacturing disclosure names FDA registration and cGMP compliance but does not name a facility, city, or state anywhere in the published pages.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Experts/testing/manufacturing corrected November 14, 2026; five criteria dated July 3Sources: 19 dated source records; individual evidence dates retainedFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth Glandex review →
    20
    G
    Glandex
    Vetnique Labs LLC
    Experts corrected 7→10, testing 4→6 and manufacturing 7→8 on November 14 to credit full named expert roles, the NASC testing programme and stated FDA-registered cGMP USA facilit...
    70.5/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  21. 21
    Rank
    VD

    VitaDog

    VitaDog Nutrition Inc.

    Dover, Delaware (registered address; manufacturing facility not disclosed)
    70.5/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Solid With Gaps

    VitaDog has a real editorial-policy spine, a substantive peer-reviewed sources page, named third-party testing, and a named (if country-level-only) manufacturing quality standard — but the badge stack (Vet Reviewed, Clinically Dosed, Public Eurofins COAs) overpromises against the underlying surface. The testing panel is microbiology-only on one SKU, the brand's own 'vet-led advisory board' has no named members while a named outside DVM reviewer has a documented, expressly editorial role, no finished-formula trial exists, and no manufacturing facility is named. Stronger than the median DTC peer on editorial-policy and quality-system scaffolding; weaker than the marketing implies on named-expert substance.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Publishes a substantive 41-entry peer-reviewed sources library with PubMed IDs and DOIs, verified in full against the live page (41 PMIDs, 41 PubMed links, 36 DOIs).
    • Publishes an editorial policy and a named outside DVM reviewer with explicit qualifications and article-review scope; product formulation and endorsement are excluded from that role.
    • Names Eurofins (ISO/IEC 17025:2017) as testing partner and publishes two per-lot COA PDFs, plus names cGMP as its manufacturing quality standard.

    What's not in it

    • Eurofins COAs cover microbiology only (E. coli, Salmonella, Yeast, Mold) — no heavy metals, no pesticides, no potency on actives disclosed in the published COAs.
    • The formulation-side vet-led advisory board remains unnamed. Samantha Zebley’s disclosed outside editorial role does not establish product formulation, evaluation or endorsement.
    • No manufacturing facility name, city, or state is disclosed anywhere on the site; disclosure stops at 'US-based facility' plus the named cGMP standard.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    21
    VD
    VitaDog
    VitaDog Nutrition Inc.
    VitaDog has a real editorial-policy spine, a substantive peer-reviewed sources page, named third-party testing, and a named (if country-level-only) manufacturing quality standar...
    70.5/100
    Solid With Gaps
    Full review →
  22. Virbac product photo
    22
    Rank
    69.5/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps
    22
    Rank
    Virbac

    Virbac

    Virbac Corporation

    Westlake, Texas, United States
    69.5/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps

    Virbac is a sourceable veterinary-channel brand with stronger dental evidence signals than many supplement brands, especially through VOHC, and a named credentialed veterinarian and quality/compliance officer in public leadership bios. The buyer still has to assemble label detail, manufacturing geography, and expert roles from several disconnected public sources, and lot-level testing evidence remains unpublished.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility
    Worth Noting

    Active Identity Withheld

    The brand uses proprietary blends, grouped amounts, or other label conventions that prevent a buyer from reading the per-active dose on at least one product in the line. Distinct from Line Inconsistency — captures the case where actives are hidden, not where products differ.

    What's in it

    • VOHC acceptance gives the C.E.T. dental line a buyer-visible external dental-claim signal, and one veterinary product page publishes a 4-item numbered study reference list.
    • Public pages disclose headquarters, a St. Louis-area manufacturing facility, and a named Vice President whose role covers FDA and worldwide GMP compliance.
    • A named, fully-credentialed veterinarian (Dr. Alan Taylor, holding a Bachelor's degree in Veterinary Medicine and Surgery from the University of Glasgow) is surfaced in primary navigation, though not tied to the C.E.T. line by name.

    What's not in it

    • Full active-by-active amounts are not consistently published on official product pages.
    • No buyer-facing lot-level COA lookup or named laboratory panel was surfaced despite dedicated sitemap and common-handle probing.
    • The named veterinarian's and quality officer's disclosed scope covers Virbac North America broadly, not the C.E.T. supplement or dental line specifically, and one product page's footnote citation numbering does not resolve to its reference list.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Reviewed Jul 3, 2026Sources: 15 sources reviewedFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth Virbac review →
    22
    Virbac
    Virbac
    Virbac Corporation
    Virbac is a sourceable veterinary-channel brand with stronger dental evidence signals than many supplement brands, especially through VOHC, and a named credentialed veterinarian...
    Active Identity Withheld
    69.5/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  23. Nordic Naturals Pet product photo
    23
    Rank
    69/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    23
    Rank
    Nordic Naturals Pet

    Nordic Naturals Pet

    Nordic Naturals, Inc.

    Watsonville, California, United States
    69/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    Nordic Naturals Pet gives buyers a public testing and quality trail centered on a lot-linked COA pathway, a named Norway manufacturing facility (Nordic Pharma), an NASC-audited facility relationship, and fish-oil sourcing certifications. A second production step (Southern California bottling/encapsulation) and an NSF-specific facility certification are disclosed but remain single-sourced without independent corroboration. Current expert roles, complete official-page text labels for the soft-chew line, pet-specific sample COAs, and named testing laboratories are not all surfaced from a buyer-verifiable hub.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • The Nordic Promise and product pages give buyers a lot-linked COA pathway with potency, purity, and freshness framing.
    • Nordic Naturals names its primary fish-oil manufacturing facility (Nordic Pharma, Tromso, Norway) on its own site and has passed an independent NASC facility audit with Quality Seal permission, alongside Friend of the Sea and third-party non-GMO sourcing certifications.
    • The pet microsite and Q&A PDF provide omega-3 rationale, a named veterinary nutrition author, and study citations, though the citation set and author byline are dated to 2010.

    What's not in it

    • The named veterinary nutrition expert is surfaced only in a 2010-dated educational PDF and does not appear on any current (2026) Nordic Naturals pet page checked.
    • The official joint, skin, and digestive soft-chew product pages do not publish numeric supplement-facts or guaranteed-analysis panels in accessible text; the per-mg figures are reachable only via a third-party retailer page.
    • Current product pages use research-backed phrasing without linking each claim to finished-formula study metadata, and no third-party testing laboratory or NSF-specific facility certification is independently corroborated on any reachable page.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    23
    Nordic Naturals Pet
    Nordic Naturals Pet
    Nordic Naturals, Inc.
    Nordic Naturals Pet gives buyers a public testing and quality trail centered on a lot-linked COA pathway, a named Norway manufacturing facility (Nordic Pharma), an NASC-audited ...
    69/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  24. 24
    Rank
    NV

    NaturVet

    Garmon Corp. (operating as NaturVet); subsidiary of Swedencare AB

    Temecula, California
    69/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Disclosure Gaps

    Quantified sample panels, detailed quality disclosures and named veterinary roles; grouped amounts, study detail and current formulation scope remain limited.

    Public Evidence System Named Veterinary RolesIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Audited Listing Clinical Evidence Published Named Temecula Manufacturing

    What's in it

    • Quantified panels across the declared sample
    • Detailed public manufacturing, sourcing and testing descriptions
    • Named historical and educational veterinary involvement

    What's not in it

    • A grouped enzyme blend and one inconsistent published fatty-acid panel
    • Joint-study summary without a full public citation in the reviewed sources
    • Current formulation roles and lot-linked analytical reports not fully surfaced
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence reviewed Nov 11, 2026Sources: 16 source records; declared sample
    In-depth NaturVet review →
    24
    NV
    NaturVet
    Garmon Corp. (operating as NaturVet); subsidiary of Swedencare AB
    Quantified sample panels, detailed quality disclosures and named veterinary roles; grouped amounts, study detail and current formulation scope remain limited.
    69/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  25. Zesty Paws product photo
    25
    Rank
    69.0/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps
    25
    Rank
    Zesty Paws

    Zesty Paws

    Zesty Paws LLC

    United States
    69.0/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps

    Useful individual quantities on sampled labels, a published native-canine probiotic pilot, named veterinary spokespersons and an NASC audit credential. Blends, product-page/package conflicts and uneven study or lot-report detail still need exact-product checks. The 69.0/100 score measures public disclosure, not potency, safety or efficacy.

    Public Evidence System Named ExpertsIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Sampled official package images disclose many serving-based amounts; several products retain explicitly identified pooled blends.
    • The Native canine-probiotic pilot is published and names its investigators; the professional information describes observational-study limits.
    • Dated manufacturer announcements name DVM spokespersons Lindsay Butzer and Ryan Rucker.
    • NASC audit identity, GMP statements and USA/Thailand manufacturing exceptions are publicly described.

    What's not in it

    • Some website ingredient text and package images conflict. These representations cannot be merged into one verified formula; match the exact item.
    • The small uncontrolled Native pilot does not establish every retail dose or clinical efficacy; its six-of-seven alpha-diversity finding is not an 86% clinical response rate.
    • Public lot lookup is explicitly CBD-scoped. No lot was submitted in this review; the source set does not supply current lot reports for every oral product or prove that internal testing is absent.
    • Named spokesperson and study-author roles do not establish a current product-by-product formulation roster.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence and editorial review November 14, 2026Sources: 66 public evidence records / 65 unique URLs; 32 selected product pages and 21 inspected images; not a catalogue census
    In-depth Zesty Paws review →
    25
    Zesty Paws
    Zesty Paws
    Zesty Paws LLC
    Useful individual quantities on sampled labels, a published native-canine probiotic pilot, named veterinary spokespersons and an NASC audit credential. Blends, product-page/pack...
    69.0/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  26. Rx Vitamins for Pets product photo
    26
    Rank
    69/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps
    26
    Rank
    Rx Vitamins for Pets

    Rx Vitamins for Pets

    Rx Vitamins

    Oldsmar, FL
    69/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps

    Readable panels, technical references and a historically named formulator; current roles, factory geography and lot reports remain less accessible.

    Public Evidence System Named Formulator (2016/2019)Ingredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Audited Listing Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Readable manufacturer nutrient panels for the core sample
    • Public technical report with mechanisms and named references
    • Historically named credentialed formulator and independently corroborated NASC audit status

    What's not in it

    • Grouped probiotic amounts and a report species-name inconsistency
    • Historical expert records do not establish current roles
    • No manufacturing site or public lot-linked analytical report established in the reviewed sources
    • Cross-species ingredient research does not establish finished-formula outcomes
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence reviewed Nov 11, 2026Sources: 13 source records; declared sample
    In-depth Rx Vitamins for Pets review →
    26
    Rx Vitamins for Pets
    Rx Vitamins for Pets
    Rx Vitamins
    Readable panels, technical references and a historically named formulator; current roles, factory geography and lot reports remain less accessible.
    69/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  27. Wholistic Pet Organics product photo
    27
    Rank
    68.5/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Disclosure Gaps
    27
    Rank
    Wholistic Pet Organics

    Wholistic Pet Organics

    68.5/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Disclosure Gaps

    68.5/100 under the existing brand-disclosure rubric. Quantified labels, public quality systems and accessible company information earn substantial credit; citation presentation, role specificity and mixed dose formats leave defined gaps.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Quantitative information exists across all eight sampled products, with explicit differences in completeness.
    • Named facility, quality programs, sourcing controls and traceability are publicly described.
    • NASC participation has independent directory corroboration; quality and family information are accessible through primary navigation.

    What's not in it

    • The declared sample covers eight products across six functional/form categories, including both dog and cat Complete. It is representative editorial sampling, not a census of every SKU, horse product or market.
    • Current disclosures are scored as current. Historical archives demonstrate specific old errors but do not establish that every new page element existed in May or July.
    • The public testing score does not verify laboratory execution, certificate validity, safety, efficacy or every lot.
    • Clinical and claim-discipline findings are limited to the specified pages; failed search queries are not evidence of universal absence.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Reviewed November 11, 2026Sources: Dated primary sources; criterion mappings in the dataset
    In-depth Wholistic Pet Organics review →
    27
    Wholistic Pet Organics
    Wholistic Pet Organics
    68.5/100 under the existing brand-disclosure rubric. Quantified labels, public quality systems and accessible company information earn substantial credit; citation presentation,...
    68.5/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  28. Vet's Best product photo
    28
    Rank
    68.5/100
    as of 2026-11-12
    Disclosure Gaps
    28
    Rank
    Vet's Best

    Vet's Best

    Compana Pet Brands — public parent-company portfolio

    Dog and cat supplements
    68.5/100
    as of 2026-11-12
    Disclosure Gaps

    Quantitative package panels, a named DVM founder and broader NASC/US-manufacture disclosures; current reviewer identities, matched studies and public lot reports remain limited.

    Public Evidence System Historical DVM FounderIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Audited Listing Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA

    What's in it

    • Numerical panels, including quantitative images missed by text-only extraction
    • Named credentialed founder and specific historical role in primary-navigation About
    • NASC program listing and country-level manufacturing disclosures across multiple formulas

    What's not in it

    • Several grouped quantities and five HTML panels without an independently verified serving heading
    • NASC program participation does not expose specific lot results or a named testing lab
    • Historical founder disclosure does not name current reviewers of each supplement
    • Some published directions and one joint-panel amount conflict
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence and editorial review November 12, 2026Sources: 32 primary sources; declared 14-formula sample
    In-depth Vet's Best review →
    28
    Vet's Best
    Vet's Best
    Compana Pet Brands — public parent-company portfolio
    Quantitative package panels, a named DVM founder and broader NASC/US-manufacture disclosures; current reviewer identities, matched studies and public lot reports remain limited.
    68.5/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  29. 29
    Rank
    HP

    Honest Paws

    Honest Paws, LLC

    League City, Texas, United States
    68/100
    as of 2026-06-13
    Disclosure Gaps

    Honest Paws operates one of the few buyer-usable batch-linked COA lookups in the DTC pet CBD segment, with full contaminant panels from a named ISO 17025-accredited laboratory, and publishes exact CBD doses across its hemp line. Disclosure weakens off that flagship line: non-CBD products sit outside the COA tool and several omit per-active amounts, veterinary claims are not tied to named experts, and manufacturing identity stays at country level.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreePublic COA LookupPer-Lot TraceabilityNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Batch-linked Certificates of Analysis lookup covering 26 CBD product types and 154 batches, serving full-panel PDFs — cannabinoid potency, pesticides, mycotoxins, residual solvents, heavy metals, and microbiology — from SC Laboratories, an ISO 17025-accredited laboratory named on every report.
    • CBD-line label disclosure is consistent and exact: every bite, soft chew, and tincture strength publishes hemp-oil mg with naturally occurring CBD mg per serving, plus itemized inactives and weight-banded feeding charts.
    • NASC Quality Seal disclosure goes beyond the badge — a dedicated page documents biennial third-party audits, adverse event reporting, a Quality Control Manual, and GMP adherence, and PDPs identify the brand as an audited NASC Primary Supplier Member.

    What's not in it

    • Veterinary involvement is asserted sitewide ('Vet Recommended', 'Veterinarian-reviewed') but never connected to a named individual; the DVM bios that exist are unlinked team pages that state no formulation, review, or advisory role.
    • The non-CBD line discloses materially less than the CBD line: no non-CBD product appears in the COA lookup, the Multivitamin omits vitamin amounts but quantifies selected actives, Fish Oil publishes EPA and DHA percentages, and Probiotics and Turkey Tail hold part of their panels at blend-level totals.
    • Manufacturing identity is held at country level — 'USA made' with GMP and NASC language but no facility name, city, or state, and no FDA facility-registration disclosure.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Label quantities and formal expert flag corrected November 14, 2026; criterion values unchangedSources: 20 sources reviewed
    In-depth Honest Paws review →
    29
    HP
    Honest Paws
    Honest Paws, LLC
    Honest Paws operates one of the few buyer-usable batch-linked COA lookups in the DTC pet CBD segment, with full contaminant panels from a named ISO 17025-accredited laboratory, ...
    68/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  30. True Leaf Pet product photo
    30
    Rank
    68/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    30
    Rank
    True Leaf Pet

    True Leaf Pet

    Trueleaf Petcare Inc.

    Vernon, British Columbia, Canada
    68/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    Named veterinary co-founder, active-amount panels and an own plant in Vernon, British Columbia. The ingredient-COA programme remains described rather than publicly accessible; facility certification scope is incomplete.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Quality Seal Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • A named, fully credentialed co-founder veterinarian (Dr. Daniela Fischer, DVM/MSc/PhD) is disclosed on both the homepage and the primary-nav ingredients page, with a stated role overseeing product formulas.
    • Rare hemp honesty — 'Our products don't contain any cannabinoids' — with THC-absence testing stated, external claim review via the Canadian Veterinary Health Product designation, and NASC regulations followed in the US.
    • Full per-active mg panels with no proprietary blends were confirmed across five checked SKUs spanning three of the four product families, plus a named own plant in Vernon, British Columbia and named Saskatchewan hemp sourcing.

    What's not in it

    • The described ingredient-COA program is unpublished: no named lab, no public certificate, no lot access, confirmed across all 15 archived pages and direct handle probes for common COA/quality-page URLs.
    • Four of four calming-line product pages checked use unqualified 'clinically studied'/'clinically researched' language with no study, author, or journal surfaced anywhere on the reviewed surfaces.
    • The own plant is identified in Vernon, British Columbia, but the reviewed current pages do not publish facility-level cGMP, HACCP, SQF or ISO certification documents.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    C6 and badge corrected Nov 15, 2026; other criteria Jul 3, 2026Sources: 13 original sources; 3 bounded correction sourcesFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth True Leaf Pet review →
    30
    True Leaf Pet
    True Leaf Pet
    Trueleaf Petcare Inc.
    Named veterinary co-founder, active-amount panels and an own plant in Vernon, British Columbia. The ingredient-COA programme remains described rather than publicly accessible; f...
    68/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  31. Tomlyn product photo
    31
    Rank
    67.5/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps
    31
    Rank
    Tomlyn

    Tomlyn

    Vetoquinol USA, Inc.

    67.5/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps

    Tomlyn publishes quantitative labels across most sampled oral products, named veterinary contributions and an L-lysine citation. NASC corroborates its supplier status; grouped amounts and purchased-lot documentation remain the practical gaps.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • All four current Nutri-Cal galleries link quantitative Guaranteed Analysis panels per teaspoon (6 g); other sampled oral ranges also print active amounts.
    • Historical company interviews name Dr. Jim Lowe and Dr. Jim Spiezio; Spiezio credits specific product-development work. L-lysine pages publish an identifiable ingredient-study citation.
    • NASC’s own supplier listing corroborates audited status and seal permission. Current labels disclose Canada or USA manufacture, depending on the product.

    What's not in it

    • Pre & Probiotic and Dermal Soothe retain major pooled or preparation-level quantities.
    • NASC participation includes a random independent-product-testing requirement, but no named analytical laboratory or purchased-lot result is identified by the reviewed programme records.
    • The named expert biographies are historical and do not establish current formulation responsibility for every product. Specific manufacturing facility/city and site-certification scope remain unestablished by the selected sources.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Labels/manufacturing updated Nov 14, 2026; six criteria retainedSources: 23 sources for targeted update; prior evidence retainedFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth Tomlyn review →
    31
    Tomlyn
    Tomlyn
    Vetoquinol USA, Inc.
    Tomlyn publishes quantitative labels across most sampled oral products, named veterinary contributions and an L-lysine citation. NASC corroborates its supplier status; grouped a...
    67.5/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  32. Pet Wellbeing product photo
    32
    Rank
    67/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Disclosure Gaps
    32
    Rank
    Pet Wellbeing

    Pet Wellbeing

    Louisville, KY, USA
    67/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Disclosure Gaps

    Named experts, real ingredient research and detailed testing claims; grouped herb doses and strong clinical extrapolation remain concerns.

    Public Evidence System Named ExpertsIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Audited Listing Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA
    Worth Noting

    Grouped Active Amounts

    Ingredient identities are listed; grouped amounts prevent reading each constituent’s dose.

    What's in it

    • Named veterinary formulators and advisors with credentials and roles
    • Identifiable ingredient research and detailed biological explanations
    • Public testing-method descriptions, US quality-system statements and NASC audit signal

    What's not in it

    • Life Gold and Kidney Support Gold publish blend totals rather than each herb’s amount
    • No public lot-linked analytical report or named testing laboratory located in the reviewed sources
    • Uneven separation of ingredient studies from finished-formula outcomes, plus a Milk Thistle herb-total/silymarin inconsistency
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence reviewed Nov 11, 2026Sources: 11 source records; declared sample
    In-depth Pet Wellbeing review →
    32
    Pet Wellbeing
    Pet Wellbeing
    Named experts, real ingredient research and detailed testing claims; grouped herb doses and strong clinical extrapolation remain concerns.
    Grouped Active Amounts
    67/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  33. 33
    Rank
    SPVF

    Standard Process Veterinary Formulas

    65.5/100
    as of 2026-11-11
    Disclosure Gaps

    Public product pages provide ingredient information, some active quantities and ingredient references. A public veterinary-team document and detailed manufacturing/testing disclosures also exist. Blend-level quantities and scattered evidence remain real limits.

    Public Evidence System Named Experts (2023)Ingredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Quality Seal Clinical Evidence Published Disclosed Production Sites
    Worth Noting

    Grouped Active Amounts

    The published rubric includes grouped active amounts under this watchout. Ingredient identities are listed; individual amounts are not given for each blend constituent.

    What's in it

    • Named Palmyra manufacturing campus and owned-farm sourcing disclosures
    • Specific in-house raw-material and finished-product testing program
    • Public product information and dated named veterinary-support roles

    What's not in it

    • Proprietary-blend or ingredient-list disclosure dominates the declared sample
    • Ingredient references do not establish clinical results for all finished formulas
    • The 2023 veterinary-team document is not a current employment confirmation or a formula-authorship record
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence reviewed Nov 11, 2026Sources: 8 source records; representative product sample
    In-depth Standard Process Veterinary Formulas review →
    33
    SPVF
    Standard Process Veterinary Formulas
    Public product pages provide ingredient information, some active quantities and ingredient references. A public veterinary-team document and detailed manufacturing/testing discl...
    Grouped Active Amounts
    65.5/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  34. Super Snouts product photo
    34
    Rank
    63.5/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    34
    Rank
    Super Snouts

    Super Snouts

    63.5/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    Rebuilt research record for Super Snouts from live-fetched surfaces (2026-07-03): homepage, FAQ, the informatives COA library, product pages, and — added during adversarial verification — a second COA page (Test Results) and an education page (CBD 101) discovered via sitemap and navigation inspection. Every rubric item carries verified evidence, a verbatim quote, gap, and confidence level.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility
    Worth Noting

    Active Identity Withheld

    The brand uses proprietary blends, grouped amounts, or other label conventions that prevent a buyer from reading the per-active dose on at least one product in the line. Distinct from Line Inconsistency — captures the case where actives are hidden, not where products differ.

    Unnamed Experts

    The brand uses "veterinarian formulated," "expert designed," or similar language without any publicly named individual, credentials, or role.

    What's in it

    • Public lot-linked hemp-product COAs include inspected reports issued by SC Labs; the Test Results page organizes reports by product category.
    • A real, independently-verified safety citation: the informatives page cites a peer-reviewed veterinary toxicology paper (PMID 23796481) to support its non-detectable-THC standard, honestly scoped to the safety claim rather than borrowed for efficacy.
    • Single-ingredient transparency at its best: Joint Power is '100% New Zealand Green Lipped Mussel' with weight-based dosing and loading-phase guidance; a dedicated CBD 101 page explains the water-soluble absorption mechanism in structured, buyer-facing terms.

    What's not in it

    • No named individual anywhere: veterinary direction is attributed to an unnamed supplier expert AND a separately-claimed, unnamed in-house 'Chief Veterinary Officer'; 'Veterinary recommended' badges carry no name either.
    • The earlier 8-product review’s dose-gap count is corrected: Joint Power powder and soft chews both quantify 300 mg GLM; five other products retain unresolved per-active disclosure findings.
    • The two COA archives cover the CBD/hemp product line only — none of the 8 non-CBD products reviewed for other criteria (Joint Power, Firm Up, G.I. Balance, Lion's Roar, Pumpkin Latte, Super Shrooms) appear in either archive — and the archives are not cross-linked to each other.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    34
    Super Snouts
    Super Snouts
    Rebuilt research record for Super Snouts from live-fetched surfaces (2026-07-03): homepage, FAQ, the informatives COA library, product pages, and — added during adversarial veri...
    Active Identity WithheldUnnamed Experts
    63.5/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  35. Adored Beast Apothecary product photo
    36
    Rank
    63/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    36
    Rank
    Adored Beast Apothecary

    Adored Beast Apothecary

    63/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    Verified transparency record for Adored Beast Apothecary, completed 2026-07-03. All 14 cited sources were fetched and archived; every exact_quote was confirmed verbatim against its cited source; the brand's own site was actively probed for COA, facility, and named-expert pages before any score reflecting an absence was finalized. Named-expert and scientific-rationale evidence are strong and easy to find; testing/COA and manufacturing disclosure are the brand's weakest areas.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Founder and formulator Julie Anne Lee, DCH RCSHom is named with full credentials and biographical detail on a page linked directly from the site's primary top-level navigation.
    • The flagship Healthy Gut and the Equine and Feline Gut Soothe formulas publish full per-active mg/CFU dose panels rather than a single blended total.
    • A dedicated Ingredient Glossary explains a biological mechanism, not just a benefit claim, for most of the roughly 50 actives used across the line.

    What's not in it

    • The reviewed materials do not provide a public lot-linked COA lookup, named third-party laboratory or test-panel results. The FAQ describes manufacturers serving professionals, not a policy barring retail certificate requests.
    • No manufacturing facility name, city, state, or quality-system certification (NASC, cGMP, HACCP, FDA registration, SQF, ISO) is disclosed; the only manufacturing claim found is a country-level "Handcrafted in the USA" banner.
    • Several products (Canine Gut Soothe, Gut Soothe, and the Liver Tonic component sold inside both protocol bundles) label part of their formula a proprietary blend with a total CFU or no per-active amount, while the flagship and other SKUs disclose full per-active dosing.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    C6 contradictory gap wording corrected to credit stated USA manufacture. Tier7 and total 63 unchanged; original factual evidence dates retained.Sources: 15 dated source records; individual evidence dates retainedFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth Adored Beast Apothecary review →
    36
    Adored Beast Apothecary
    Adored Beast Apothecary
    Verified transparency record for Adored Beast Apothecary, completed 2026-07-03. All 14 cited sources were fetched and archived; every exact_quote was confirmed verbatim against ...
    63/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  36. Dinovite product photo
    37
    Rank
    63.0/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps
    37
    Rank
    Dinovite

    Dinovite

    Dinovite / Compana Pet Brands

    Compana Pet Brands portfolio
    63.0/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps

    Dinovite discloses product quantities and ingredient rationales and names a PhD nutritionist across several product families. Readable ingredient studies and historical official testing records deserve credit. Grouped amounts, incomplete citation links and current lot-report limits remain.

    Public Evidence System Named PhD NutritionistIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Quality Seal Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA
    Worth Noting

    Active Identity Withheld

    Published trigger met by C1=6 and ingredient-forward products with pooled/grouped quantities; no intent inference.

    Evidence Buried

    Published trigger met by C2/C4 at least7 and C8=6; dedicated research and regulator discovery is documented.

    What's in it

    • Selected manufacturer descriptions disclose nutrient guarantees, enzyme activities, oil fatty-acid percentages and product-specific amounts. The current 29 g dental-chew table gives 250 mg COHP and a 245 mg grouped oral-health blend.
    • Three relevant oral-postbiotic papers are publicly readable. The manufacturer attributes studies to the ingredient and distinguishes clinical from in-vitro findings; these qualifications receive credit.
    • Dr. Inke Paetau-Robinson is named as a senior R&D nutritionist across core, puppy, dental and liquid product materials. Manufacturer copy identifies a PhD, supported by institutional and professional records.
    • Kentucky official reports publish historical 2023 and 2024 manufacturer/guarantor testing under Compana-Manna Pro dba Dinovite LLC. This is identifiable public testing evidence even though it is published independently of the brand.

    What's not in it

    • Core powders and Meal Booster pool microorganisms and omit some promoted ingredient amounts; dental products contain grouped blends. Tier 6 holds even if all retained descriptions are visible. The retained descriptions do not establish current package equivalence.
    • The inspected manufacturer clinical summaries do not identify authors, journals or direct paper links. Independent research was needed to connect the summaries to the papers; current supplier and exact retail-formula identity remain unestablished.
    • The historical company records do not identify the current reviewed SKU or lot, establish a brand-operated COA program, or prove current whole-line testing.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Assessed November 14, 2026Sources: 24 unique public reference destinations across ten sampled product routes and external research, professional and historical regulatory sources
    In-depth Dinovite review →
    37
    Dinovite
    Dinovite
    Dinovite / Compana Pet Brands
    Dinovite discloses product quantities and ingredient rationales and names a PhD nutritionist across several product families. Readable ingredient studies and historical official...
    Active Identity WithheldEvidence Buried
    63.0/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  37. Grizzly Pet Products product photo
    38
    Rank
    63/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    38
    Rank
    Grizzly Pet Products

    Grizzly Pet Products

    63/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    Grizzly publishes detailed omega-oil panels and ingredient rationale. NASC independently documents its quality programme, including random product testing; a primary acquisition announcement names historical founder Harald Fisker. Public lot results and current scientific credentials remain unresolved.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Every one of the 7 live product pages discloses a complete per-active mg/mcg or Guaranteed Analysis panel with a full inactive-ingredients list and zero proprietary-blend language found anywhere on the site.
    • A dedicated, primary-navigation science page explains the biological mechanism and bioavailability differences between Omega-3, -6, and -9 fatty acids, with one externally cited source for a sourcing claim.
    • NASC membership and region-level (Alaska) sourcing detail are disclosed on primary pages, though without a named facility address.
    • NASC independently confirms Quality Seal approval; its programme includes random independent-laboratory product testing.

    What's not in it

    • The reviewed materials do not identify the testing laboratory or provide public Grizzly lot results or a lot-linked COA lookup.
    • Historical founder Harald Fisker is named, but current scientific credentials and formulation responsibilities are not established.
    • The one genuine external citation found on the site supports an environmental-sourcing claim, not a health or efficacy claim, and no finished-formula clinical evidence is disclosed for any product.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    C4 4→5 and C5 1→6; total 54→63. C8 factual premise corrected with tier 6 retained. Other six numerical criteria keep July 3 evidence dates.Sources: 17 dated source records; individual evidence dates retainedFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth Grizzly Pet Products review →
    38
    Grizzly Pet Products
    Grizzly Pet Products
    Grizzly publishes detailed omega-oil panels and ingredient rationale. NASC independently documents its quality programme, including random product testing; a primary acquisition...
    63/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  38. 39
    Rank
    PFY

    Pawfy

    Pawfy Inc.

    Raleigh, NC, USA
    62/100
    as of 2026-11-15
    Disclosure Gaps

    Primary product pages disclose amounts, DVM endorsements and quality claims. Daisy May’s consultant biography is deeper; active NASC seal participation is unverified.

    Public Evidence System Named DVM EndorsersIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Seal: Unverified Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Current panels give serving-based amounts; Probiotic vitamins and organisms remain grouped.
    • Daisy May’s biography states consultant scope beyond endorsement.
    • NASC membership, cGMP and SQF are manufacturer claims.

    What's not in it

    • No named lab or public lot COA found.
    • Sampled outcome percentages lack methods.
    • Manufacturing facility identity and active NASC seal participation are not established.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Expert role checked Nov 15; other criterion dates retainedSources: 20 cited source records; individual dates vary
    In-depth Pawfy review →
    39
    PFY
    Pawfy
    Pawfy Inc.
    Primary product pages disclose amounts, DVM endorsements and quality claims. Daisy May’s consultant biography is deeper; active NASC seal participation is unverified.
    62/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  39. Animal Essentials product photo
    40
    Rank
    59.5/100
    as of 2026-11-14 (C5); other criteria dated 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    40
    Rank
    Animal Essentials

    Animal Essentials

    59.5/100
    as of 2026-11-14 (C5); other criteria dated 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    Animal Essentials names an advisory veterinarian and describes its manufacturing program. Three sampled Apawthecary herbal blends use combined amounts; B-Complex separately lists vitamin quantities. Testing is corrected 4→6 for the independently confirmed NASC programme; total 59.5/100, with blend-scope and claim-wording corrections dated November 14.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility
    Worth Noting

    Active Identity Withheld

    The brand uses proprietary blends, grouped amounts, or other label conventions that prevent a buyer from reading the per-active dose on at least one product in the line. Distinct from Line Inconsistency — captures the case where actives are hidden, not where products differ.

    What's in it

    • A named individual, Dr. Evelyn Kass Williamson, is identified as a Veterinary Advisory Board member with a defined role, reachable from primary navigation.
    • The FAQ discloses FDA-registered, GMP-compliant manufacturing and NASC certification, and every checked product page carries a consistent per-ingredient mechanism-level rationale section.
    • The UT-Grav FAQ expressly frames the product as urinary support rather than an infection or stone treatment; other detailed passages contain infection-related contexts, so the prior uniformly support-only description is corrected.

    What's not in it

    • Bos-Curcuma, RespiCalm and UT-Grav give combined herbal-blend totals rather than each herb’s amount. B-Complex separately quantifies vitamins and should not be grouped with these blend-only panels.
    • No ingredient-level study, author, or named finished-formula trial was found anywhere on the site.
    • NASC independently confirms participation in its audited testing programme, but the reviewed sources do not name a laboratory or provide public lot-linked results.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Testing, label/claim wording and flags corrected November 14, 2026; seven criteria dated July 3Sources: 18 dated source records; individual evidence dates retainedFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth Animal Essentials review →
    40
    Animal Essentials
    Animal Essentials
    Animal Essentials names an advisory veterinarian and describes its manufacturing program. Three sampled Apawthecary herbal blends use combined amounts; B-Complex separately list...
    Active Identity Withheld
    59.5/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  40. NUPRO Supplements product photo
    41
    Rank
    59/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps
    41
    Rank
    NUPRO Supplements

    NUPRO Supplements

    Nutri-Pet Research, Inc.

    Manalapan, NJ, US
    59/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps

    Quantified added ingredients, five-mineral analysis and NASC status; base quantities, named expertise and analytical-report disclosure remain limited.

    Public Evidence System Named ExpertsIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Audited Listing Clinical Evidence Published Made In USA
    Worth Noting

    Undisclosed Base Amounts

    Gold/Joint base ingredient amounts are not disclosed. Joint separately quantifies its added actives, including 200 mg Ester-C blend rather than isolated vitamin C.

    Unnamed Formulation Expertise

    Reviewed sources use anonymous nutrition/veterinary-development framing without a named individual.

    What's in it

    • Quantitative added-ingredient and electrolyte disclosures
    • Ingredient-role explanations and clear scoop/weight guidance
    • NASC audited-member confirmation and a lot-code/expiry explanation

    What's not in it

    • Base whole-food quantities are not disclosed in the reviewed Gold/Joint pages
    • No named formulator, study citation or public analytical-report route located in the declared sources
    • Broad completeness and detoxification claims lack a directly matched public evidentiary explanation
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Evidence reviewed Nov 11, 2026Sources: 13 source records; declared sample
    In-depth NUPRO Supplements review →
    41
    NUPRO Supplements
    NUPRO Supplements
    Nutri-Pet Research, Inc.
    Quantified added ingredients, five-mineral analysis and NASC status; base quantities, named expertise and analytical-report disclosure remain limited.
    Undisclosed Base AmountsUnnamed Formulation Expertise
    59/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  41. BIXBI product photo
    42
    Rank
    58/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    42
    Rank
    BIXBI

    BIXBI

    Boulder, Colorado
    58/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    BIXBI publishes detailed food/treat testing and quality-system information, while the sampled supplement lines vary in label detail. Named formulation personnel and supplement-specific laboratory/lot documentation remain unresolved.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility
    Worth Noting

    Unnamed Experts

    The brand uses "veterinarian formulated," "expert designed," or similar language without any publicly named individual, credentials, or role.

    What's in it

    • Hip-and-joint jerky treats disclose exact per-active doses (Glucosamine 2,400 mg/kg min, Chondroitin Sulfate 1,200 mg/kg min) on the guaranteed-analysis panel.
    • The food-safety pages name tested contaminants and pathogens; the dry-food quality-assurance page describes a batch-release testing gate.
    • The mushroom-supplement page states NASC Audited Member and USA Made; separate food-manufacturing pages describe facility quality systems.

    What's not in it

    • No individual formulator, nutritionist, or veterinarian is named anywhere on the public site; only role/credential descriptions are given.
    • The reviewed sources do not identify a testing laboratory for the sampled mushroom/functional-jerky supplement lines or provide public supplement lot COAs.
    • All four mushroom-supplement SKUs disclose their active mushroom-species blend only as one combined milligram weight, not per-species amounts.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Testing text scoped to food/treat versus supplement lines; tier 7 and total 58 retained. Unsupported formal Line Inconsistency flag removed; factual label differences remain.Sources: 26 dated source records; individual evidence dates retainedFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth BIXBI review →
    42
    BIXBI
    BIXBI
    BIXBI publishes detailed food/treat testing and quality-system information, while the sampled supplement lines vary in label detail. Named formulation personnel and supplement-s...
    Unnamed Experts
    58/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  42. Dr. Harvey's product photo
    43
    Rank
    58/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    43
    Rank
    Dr. Harvey's

    Dr. Harvey's

    58/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    Verified transparency record for Dr. Harvey's. Twelve public sources were fetched and archived on 2026-07-03; every rubric item was checked against the archived HTML, and every exact_quote was confirmed to appear verbatim in its cited source. Absence claims (named experts, facility identity, COA access) were actively probed via the site's XML sitemap and direct URL checks before being confirmed or refuted.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility
    Worth Noting

    Active Identity Withheld

    The brand uses proprietary blends, grouped amounts, or other label conventions that prevent a buyer from reading the per-active dose on at least one product in the line. Distinct from Line Inconsistency — captures the case where actives are hidden, not where products differ.

    What's in it

    • Manufacturing facility is named at the street, city, and state level (200 Industrial Way West, Eatontown, NJ) with disclosed NASC membership, FDA registration, and cGMP language.
    • Two named individuals are connected to the brand: formulation lead Dr. Michael Shen and veterinary endorser Dr. Julia Roach, though neither page states a formal credential.
    • Several product label panels, including Coenzyme Q10 and the Allergy + Immune Soft Chews, disclose full per-active milligram amounts rather than a combined blend total.

    What's not in it

    • The flagship Ortho Flex joint-support supplement discloses its 26 named actives, including Chondroitin Sulfate, as a single 3.3-gram 'proprietary Blend' with no per-active amounts.
    • No archived page cites a specific study, author, journal, or clinical trial for any ingredient or finished product.
    • No public lot-linked COA lookup or named third-party testing laboratory was found; direct probes of /pages/coa, /pages/quality, and similar handles returned 404.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    QC and label-count wording corrected November 14, 2026; numerical assessment July 3Sources: 14 dated source records; individual evidence dates retained
    In-depth Dr. Harvey's review →
    43
    Dr. Harvey's
    Dr. Harvey's
    Verified transparency record for Dr. Harvey's. Twelve public sources were fetched and archived on 2026-07-03; every rubric item was checked against the archived HTML, and every ...
    Active Identity Withheld
    58/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  43. 44
    Rank
    PNC

    PetNC Natural Care

    21st Century HealthCare, Inc.

    58/100
    as of 2026-11-14
    Disclosure Gaps

    PetNC publishes complete sampled dose panels and names Tempe manufacturing with GMP/NASC language. Its parent company also describes an accredited laboratory; the reviewed material does not establish that laboratory’s PetNC assay scope or provide lot results. Testing programme evidence corrected November 14, 2026; other criterion dates retained.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility
    Worth Noting

    Unnamed Experts

    The brand uses "veterinarian formulated," "expert designed," or similar language without any publicly named individual, credentials, or role.

    What's in it

    • The brand's own product pages disclose a complete active-by-active milligram panel, confirmed consistent across four different product categories.
    • The official PetNC page and three independent corroborating sources name the manufacturing facility's city and state (Tempe, AZ) along with GMP compliance and NASC Quality Seal status.
    • Marketing language stays within joint-support and quality-of-life framing without disease-treatment claims or unqualified clinical-certainty language.

    What's not in it

    • No named veterinarian, nutritionist, or product reviewer was found after an active search across 13 public sources.
    • The parent company describes an ISO/IEC 17025:2017-accredited laboratory, but the reviewed material does not link its accreditation scope to PetNC assays or provide a PetNC lot-specific COA.
    • The brand does not cite any clinical studies or distinguish ingredient-level research from finished-formula evidence anywhere in the reviewed public sources.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Laboratory disclosure corrected November 14, 2026; numerical assessment July 3Sources: 16 dated source records; individual evidence dates retainedFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth PetNC Natural Care review →
    44
    PNC
    PetNC Natural Care
    21st Century HealthCare, Inc.
    PetNC publishes complete sampled dose panels and names Tempe manufacturing with GMP/NASC language. Its parent company also describes an accredited laboratory; the reviewed mater...
    Unnamed Experts
    58/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  44. Wonder Paws product photo
    45
    Rank
    56.5/100
    as of 2026-11-15
    Disclosure Gaps
    45
    Rank
    Wonder Paws

    Wonder Paws

    56.5/100
    as of 2026-11-15
    Disclosure Gaps

    NASC-audited programme, a visible named DVM recommendation and a current flagship label; separate advertorial study and specialty claims remain unresolved.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility
    Worth Noting

    Borrowed Evidence

    The brand uses "clinically tested," "clinically proven," "study-backed," or trial-adjacent language without surfacing finished-formula or properly qualified ingredient-level evidence.

    What's in it

    • A coherent program-level quality stack on a dedicated NASC page: primary-supplier status, completed NASC audit, GMP adherence, FDA-registered USA production — three named quality-system elements together, not just one.
    • Current Collagen 3X manufacturer label prints combined collagen 600 mg and hyaluronic acid 5 mg per 2 mL, inactive carriers and 120 mL volume; Chewy lists HA 10 mg, so the source version matters.
    • Dr. Paula Simons, DVM is directly visible on the homepage and product page; product and quality information are reachable through ordinary navigation.

    What's not in it

    • Separate advertorials claim a dermatology specialty and co-design role for Dr. Paula Simons; the reviewed institutional profile confirms DVM, DACVECC but does not establish those additional claims.
    • The quoted canine Kim 2018 citation was not verified. The identifiable Nutrients paper concerns humans and cannot substantiate it; the conference-study and 12% absorption claims also lack usable citations in the reviewed sources.
    • NASC confirms audited programme participation, including random independent product testing; the reviewed programme records do not publish a named laboratory, analytical panel or lot result. This flagship correction does not establish complete disclosure across the line.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Label, expert and access checked Nov 15, 2026; other criterion dates retainedSources: 26 cited source records; individual dates varyFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth Wonder Paws review →
    45
    Wonder Paws
    Wonder Paws
    NASC-audited programme, a visible named DVM recommendation and a current flagship label; separate advertorial study and specialty claims remain unresolved.
    Borrowed Evidence
    56.5/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  45. Dogzymes product photo
    46
    Rank
    55.5/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    46
    Rank
    Dogzymes

    Dogzymes

    Nature's Farmacy

    Jasper, Georgia, United States
    55.5/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    Dogzymes has one of the better label-access paths among small supplement brands, especially for probiotics and its multinutrient flagship, with per-active guaranteed analysis on most SKUs reviewed. Its public footprint still lacks named veterinary or formulation experts, third-party lab testing records, a disclosed manufacturing facility, and study citations, and one product in the line uses an undosed proprietary blend.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility
    Worth Noting

    Unnamed Experts

    The brand uses "veterinarian formulated," "expert designed," or similar language without any publicly named individual, credentials, or role.

    What's in it

    • Most product pages disclose CFU counts, named microorganisms, and per-active guaranteed analysis with no proprietary blend.
    • Official pages explain probiotic, prebiotic, enzyme, and sourcing rationale, including one specific ingredient-selection example (algal oil vs. fish oil).
    • The company names its founder and leadership by name with a public origin story, though not as credentialed veterinary or formulation experts.

    What's not in it

    • No named veterinarian, nutritionist, microbiologist, or credentialed formulation reviewer was found — only a named founder with a non-credentialed, experience-based background.
    • No public COA lookup, named lab, lot-specific report, or manufacturing facility disclosure was found.
    • One product (Pancreas Support) bundles seven named ingredients into a single undosed proprietary blend line, and evidence pages are reachable only through the footer, not primary navigation.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Identity wording corrected Nov 15, 2026; score Jul 3, 2026Sources: 18 original sources; 1 bounded identity correction sourceFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth Dogzymes review →
    46
    Dogzymes
    Dogzymes
    Nature's Farmacy
    Dogzymes has one of the better label-access paths among small supplement brands, especially for probiotics and its multinutrient flagship, with per-active guaranteed analysis on...
    Unnamed Experts
    55.5/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  46. Ark Naturals product photo
    47
    Rank
    55/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    47
    Rank
    Ark Naturals

    Ark Naturals

    55/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    Verified transparency record for Ark Naturals, current as of the 2026-07-03 research pass. All 8 rubric criteria were re-scored against verbatim quotes from freshly archived source pages, including a sitemap-based check for pages the brand does not link from its own navigation.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility
    Worth Noting

    Unnamed Experts

    The brand uses "veterinarian formulated," "expert designed," or similar language without any publicly named individual, credentials, or role.

    What's in it

    • Two secondary supplement SKUs (Joint Rescue, Happy Traveler) disclose complete active-by-active mg amounts with weight-tiered feeding directions.
    • A dedicated science article, reachable from primary navigation, explains the dental line's antioxidant ingredient with two verifiable PubMed citations and an explicit disease-claim disclaimer.
    • USA manufacture and independently confirmed NASC facility-audit/Quality Seal eligibility are disclosed; the manufacturer’s facility identity remains unspecified.

    What's not in it

    • The clinical plaque/tartar percentage claims still lack a working underlying study report in the reviewed clinical page; Protection+ active amounts are disclosed on the package images.
    • No named veterinarian, formulator, or scientific advisor was found anywhere across 16 pages fetched in this pass.
    • The NASC programme requires random independent-lab product testing, but the reviewed programme records do not name the lab or provide Ark-specific results, panels or public lot COAs.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    47
    Ark Naturals
    Ark Naturals
    Verified transparency record for Ark Naturals, current as of the 2026-07-03 research pass. All 8 rubric criteria were re-scored against verbatim quotes from freshly archived sou...
    Unnamed Experts
    55/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  47. The Honest Kitchen product photo
    48
    Rank
    54/100
    as of 2026-11-14 (C5/C6); other criteria dated 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    48
    Rank
    The Honest Kitchen

    The Honest Kitchen

    The Honest Kitchen

    54/100
    as of 2026-11-14 (C5/C6); other criteria dated 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    The Why Human Grade page describes supplier COAs and finished-product pathogen testing before release, plus random third-party contaminant screening. Laboratory identity and exact supplement lot documents remain unresolved. Testing corrected 5→6 and manufacturing 7→8 on November 14; six other numerical criteria retain the July 3 assessment.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility
    Worth Noting

    Active Identity Withheld

    The brand uses proprietary blends, grouped amounts, or other label conventions that prevent a buyer from reading the per-active dose on at least one product in the line. Distinct from Line Inconsistency — captures the case where actives are hidden, not where products differ.

    What's in it

    • Perfect Form names active ingredients per one teaspoon and states there are no inactive ingredients.
    • The Why Human Grade page cites current good manufacturing practices and 21 CFR 117 for its human-food-facility standard, and discloses a supplier-level Certificate of Analysis requirement for incoming ingredients. The same page describes finished-product pathogen retesting before release and random third-party contaminant screening.
    • The Vet Resources page names one veterinarian, Dr. Leilani Alvarez, DVM, DACVSMR, with a quoted endorsement, and references an independent ISO accredited laboratory used for recipe nutrient testing.

    What's not in it

    • No public COA lookup or named third-party laboratory was found for Perfect Form or any other supplement/broth batch.
    • The formulation team behind The Honest Kitchen's recipes ('leading veterinarians... nutritionists and PhD food scientists') is never named; the one named veterinarian gives a customer-style testimonial, not a formulation or advisory role.
    • Perfect Form and two other supplement-line SKUs checked do not disclose individual active amounts, and none has a clinical citation tied to the finished product.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Testing/manufacturing corrected November 14, 2026; six criteria dated July 3Sources: 16 dated source records; individual evidence dates retainedFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth The Honest Kitchen review →
    48
    The Honest Kitchen
    The Honest Kitchen
    The Honest Kitchen
    The Why Human Grade page describes supplier COAs and finished-product pathogen testing before release, plus random third-party contaminant screening. Laboratory identity and exa...
    Active Identity Withheld
    54/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  48. Coco and Luna product photo
    49
    Rank
    53.5/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    49
    Rank
    Coco and Luna

    Coco and Luna

    53.5/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    November 14 correction of label, manufacturing and accessibility criteria using current product galleries and navigation. Twenty-two of 30 formula/format families inspected; five other numerical criteria and their original July 3 evidence dates retained.

    Public Evidence System Named ExpertIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility

    What's in it

    • Quantitative panels are linked in current product galleries across tablets, soft chews and cat powders.
    • The homepage identifies Caroline Hood as the named veterinary approver; scope and credentials remain limited.
    • The current Mushroom Complex package visibly states USA manufacturing and GMP certification.

    What's not in it

    • Several formulas retain grouped microorganism, enzyme or mushroom amounts.
    • The reviewed clinical-study percentages do not identify the supporting study or methods.
    • The reviewed sources do not name a testing laboratory or link a lot-specific COA.
    Why this score
    itap any criterion for evidence
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    C1/C6/C8 corrected November 14, 2026; five other criteria dated July 3Sources: 37 dated source records; individual evidence dates retained
    In-depth Coco and Luna review →
    49
    Coco and Luna
    Coco and Luna
    November 14 correction of label, manufacturing and accessibility criteria using current product galleries and navigation. Twenty-two of 30 formula/format families inspected; fiv...
    53.5/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →
  49. kin+kind product photo
    50
    Rank
    53/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps
    50
    Rank
    kin+kind

    kin+kind

    53/100
    as of 2026-07-03
    Disclosure Gaps

    Verified transparency record for kin+kind following a hostile adversarial pass completed 2026-07-03. All 15 sources were fetched and archived; every rubric criterion's exact_quote was checked verbatim against the archived HTML, with 2 of 8 quotes replaced after the originals were found to be non-evidentiary UI-chrome text. Every absence claim (named veterinarian, facility-level quality certification, COA lookup) was actively probed via sitemap enumeration and direct URL testing before being confirmed. All 8 criteria are marked verified with score_status locked and anchor language cited in the evidence text.

    Public Evidence System Named Vet ReviewerIngredient RationaleDisease-Claim-FreeNASC Member Finished-Formula Trial Named Mfg Facility
    Worth Noting

    Active Identity Withheld

    The brand uses proprietary blends, grouped amounts, or other label conventions that prevent a buyer from reading the per-active dose on at least one product in the line. Distinct from Line Inconsistency — captures the case where actives are hidden, not where products differ.

    Unnamed Experts

    The brand uses "veterinarian formulated," "expert designed," or similar language without any publicly named individual, credentials, or role.

    What's in it

    • The Flea+Tick spray line publishes a full active-ingredient percentage panel directly on the product page (e.g., Peppermint Oil 1.00%, Rosemary Oil 1.00%, Cedarwood Oil 0.20%).
    • A real facility location (New Jersey) is disclosed for its US manufacturing, and the Hip+Joint supplement's curcumin-bioavailability claims link two live, publicly-accessible NCBI/PubMed articles as ingredient-level research.
    • Evidence pages for ingredients, manufacturing, and the vet-formulated claim are reachable in one click from a primary-header dropdown menu on every page of the site.

    What's not in it

    • The veterinarian behind the brand's repeated 'vet formulated' and 'designed by our own veterinarian' claims is never named or credentialed anywhere in the site's public footprint, including on a page built specifically around that claim.
    • No third-party testing laboratory, certificate-of-analysis lookup, or contaminant/microbial/potency panel is disclosed anywhere on the site; direct probes of common transparency-page handles (COA, lab-results, quality-assurance, testing) all returned HTTP 404.
    • The Flea+Tick line's above-the-fold 'CLINICALLY PROVEN FLEA & TICK REPELLENCY... Tested to deliver over 90% efficacy' claim has no visible study, author, or citation anywhere it appears, despite the brand showing real citation discipline for its supplement line.
    Why this score
    — —
    Why this score

    What's missing

    Brand's own words
    Facility/flag correction November 14, 2026; numerical assessment July 3Sources: 16 dated source records; individual evidence dates retainedFull per-criterion evidence: public dataset ↗
    In-depth kin+kind review →
    50
    kin+kind
    kin+kind
    Verified transparency record for kin+kind following a hostile adversarial pass completed 2026-07-03. All 15 sources were fetched and archived; every rubric criterion's exact_quo...
    Active Identity WithheldUnnamed Experts
    53/100
    Disclosure Gaps
    Full review →

La Petite Labs — publisher benchmark

82.5/100 under the published rubric.

Substantial public ingredient, research, expert and testing disclosure, with gaps in lipid detail, lot coverage and consistency of claims.

Criterion scores and reasons
CriterionScoreWeightEvidence and limits
label dose transparency8/1015Both underlying formulas publish individual quantities and serving sizes:17 active lines for Hollywood Elixir and 13 for Pet Gala. Pet Gala also markets the omega 3, 6 and 9 components separately while giving their combined 150 mg amount. The omega mixture is a meaningful skin/barrier component, not a minor secondary ambiguity; individual fatty-acid amounts and source remain unspecified. This meets most-products disclosure at 8 rather than complete-line 9/10.
scientific rationale disclosure9/1010Both products have ingredient-to-role groups, research landing pages and linked species-specific frameworks covering NAD metabolism, mitochondrial cofactors, antioxidant and immune roles, structural proteins, barrier lipids, hydration and keratin nutrients. Some secondary ingredients and broad organ-support descriptions have less specific mechanism explanation. A single consolidated hub is not required by this criterion.
evidence clinical citation transparency8/1015The two research pages identify and link published studies and provide author/study context, with deeper evidence-framework links. The public product evidence is primarily ingredient, mechanistic and related-formula evidence. Prominent study cards sit beside finished-product rationale without equally explicit formula non-equivalence; the dog combination trial, feline diet trial and EPA/DHA trial cannot be described as tests of the LPL formulas. Missing finished-formula RCT s alone do not lower this criterion.
veterinary expert transparency9/1015Several named veterinarians have credentials, educational roles and biographies surfaced on the expert page, including Jo Anna Pendergrass and Sarah Calvin. Secondary contributor cards state less precise scope. Do not equate an educational contributor with the formulator of every product. The rubric does not require a named owner for every formula to earn 9.
testing coa transparency8/1015The brand names independent laboratory channels and publishes a lot-specific manufacturer COA for Hollywood Elixir 2604066 reporting microbial and heavy-metal results. The certificate also discloses its ingredient-input verification method. Pet Gala has no published lot record in the current lookup; HE formula rows are record/component-substantiated, not quantitative finished-product potency assays. Named third-party program disclosure earns 8; a manufacturer summary is not proof of complete independent lab coverage.
manufacturing quality system transparency8/1010The current shared product quality disclosure names USA, c GMP compliance and a NASC Preferred Supplier facility. NutraSky, LLC is identified as the manufacturer quality-unit issuer of the HE lot certificate. The public material does not identify the manufacturing facility by name, city and state with complete certification scope; the company name on a certificate does not establish that entire facility-level record. NASC Preferred Supplier is not an LPL product approval.
claim discipline consumer honesty7/1010Current product descriptions generally use wellness-support language and advise veterinary consultation. Some modules expressly state that products complement complete meals and veterinary care. The wider public presentation still includes complete-system framing, promised more stable or longer-lasting results, and more-years/life-ahead wording without corresponding finished-formula outcome evidence. The mixed pattern fits 7, rather than an isolated minor wording issue.
accessibility buyer verifiability9/1010The captured primary header exposes expert and product routes and a COA link; product/research/expert pages connect ingredient evidence, testing and the internal standard. Buyers can inspect the underlying material through multiple public paths. Evidence remains distributed across several destinations rather than one comprehensive trust hub. The current menu API was inaccessible to this reviewer, so no new live navigation-performance claim is made.

Sources reviewed through 11 November 2026.

Hollywood Elixir current product and linked public support fields; Pet Gala current product and linked public support fields; Pampered System current product and linked support fields; Hollywood Elixir ingredient disclosure; Pet Gala ingredient disclosure; Hollywood Elixir research landing page; Pet Gala research landing page; Named veterinary contributors; LPL-01 standard; Public lot lookup and laboratory disclosures; NutraSky manufacturer COA for Hollywood Elixir lot 2604066; Pampered explanation page; Primary navigation source

How the scores were calculated

Each criterion is assigned against the published rubric and supported by dated sources. The total is the sum of each score divided by ten and multiplied by its weight. Source selection and tier assignment require editorial judgment. The same definitions apply to the publisher benchmark, which remains outside the competitive ranking.

Ingredient or pathway coverage describes this rubric’s selected categories; it does not establish a clinical advantage. Nutrient analysis and ingredient input weight are different disclosures. Facility auditing, analytical testing and public batch reports also answer different questions.

Read the published rubric.

Corrections

Material factual errors are reviewed when identified. Please identify the exact statement and supporting source. Corrections are applied to the affected assessment, FAQs, summaries, structured data and downloadable dataset together. Additional reliable evidence may change an assessment.

Evidence dataset

Nov 15, 2026: Plano Paws label/accessibility and Pawfy expert-role corrections; other criterion dates retained.

Download the corrected dataset

Continue exploring

Common questions

What changed in this reassessment?

November 15, 2026: Plano Paws label and accessibility tiers corrected to 8/8, total 34→45; Pawfy named-expert tier corrected to 8, total 60.5→62. Pawfy’s manufacturer membership statement is retained while active NASC Quality Seal participation is unverified. Other numerical tiers and their individual evidence dates are retained.

What do these scores measure?

The published disclosure and formulation criteria. They do not establish comparative safety, clinical effectiveness or suitability for an individual animal.

Does a missing public batch report mean no testing occurs?

No. A public batch report, an analytical testing program and a facility audit are different forms of evidence.

Can additional evidence change a score?

Yes. We review specific, supported factual corrections and apply the published criterion definitions to the corrected evidence.